FireCADCalc

CO Loss (Incomplete Combustion Loss)

Boiler efficiency loss from carbon monoxide in the flue gas, from the CO reading, the fuel analysis and excess air, with the CO in mg/Nm³ (ASME PTC 4).

Thermal power plantProcess steam and utilitiesSugar mill and cogenerationRefinery and petrochemicalPulp and paperASME PTC 4 (fired steam generators)BoilerBurner and furnace

Inputs

Examples: Indian coal, 25 % excess air, 300 ppm COFuel oil, 15 % excess air, 100 ppm COBagasse, 30 % excess air, 2 000 ppm CO

Ultimate analysis, as fired, by mass

Results

CO loss, % of heat input1.7412%
Heat lost as CO1,172.9kW
CO per kg of fuel7.1469g/kg
CO concentration, dry, normal2,499.3mg/Nm³

Download PDF CSV Link to this result Compare another case

Log in to save calculations to your dashboard.

Worked example

Example: Indian coal, 25 % excess air, 300 ppm CO. The inputs, in the units selected above:

InputValue
CO in dry flue gas300.00 ppm
Carbon45.000 %
Hydrogen3.5000 %
Oxygen5.0000 %
Nitrogen1.0000 %
Sulphur0.50000 %
Ash35.000 %
Moisture10.000 %
Excess air25.000 %
Air humidity (kg water per kg dry air)0.013000 kg/kg
Gross calorific value of the fuel, as fired18,600 kJ/kg
Fuel firing rate12,000 kg/h

Applying the formula below gives:

ResultValue
CO loss, % of heat input0.27778 %
Heat lost as CO172.22 kW
CO per kg of fuel2.1863 g/kg
CO concentration, dry, normal374.90 mg/Nm³

Open this example in the calculator and change any input.

Formula

\(m_{CO} = CO_{dry}\cdot n_{dg}\cdot M_{CO} \qquad L_{CO} = \frac{m_{CO}\cdot HHV_{CO}}{GCV} \qquad \dot Q_{CO} = \dot m_f\,m_{CO}\,HHV_{CO}\)

\(c_{CO} = \frac{CO_{dry}\,M_{CO}}{V_m}\)

Variables

Symbol Meaning SI unit
\(CO_{dry}\) CO in dry flue gas, volume fraction –
\(C\), \(H\), \(O\), \(N\), \(S\), \(A\), \(M\) ultimate analysis as fired, mass fractions –
\(EA\) excess air –
\(\omega\) air humidity, kg water per kg dry air kg/kg
\(GCV\) gross calorific value J/kg
\(\dot m_f\) fuel firing rate kg/s
\(L_{CO}\) CO loss, fraction of input –
\(\dot Q_{CO}\) heat lost as CO W
\(m_{CO}\) CO per kg of fuel kg/kg
\(c_{CO}\) CO concentration, dry, at 0 °C and 101.325 kPa kg/m³
\(n_{dg}\) dry flue gas per kg of fuel, from the combustion balance kmol/kg
\(M_{CO}\) molar mass of CO, 28.010 kg/kmol kg/kmol
\(HHV_{CO}\) heat of burning CO to CO₂, 10 160 Btu/lb = 23.63 MJ/kg (PTC 4) J/kg
\(V_m\) molar volume at normal conditions, 22.414 m³/kmol m³/kmol

Method and standards

CO loss as in ASME PTC 4 §5.14: the mass of CO per kg of fuel times the heat of burning CO to CO₂, 10 160 Btu/lb, over the gross calorific value. The dry flue gas quantity comes from FireCAD's exact-ratio combustion balance of the fuel analysis at the given excess air.

Where it is used

  • Efficiency tests and combustion tuning of coal, oil, gas and biomass boilers and furnaces.
  • Setting the O₂ trim floor: the lowest O₂ before CO rises sharply.
  • Converting the analyser's ppm to mg/Nm³ for emission reports.

Common mistakes

  • Using a wet-basis CO reading with the dry gas quantity, or the reverse.
  • Reading CO at one point in a large duct: CO stratifies, so traverse the duct.
  • Looking only at the CO loss when lowering excess air, without the dry gas saving on the other side.
  • Forgetting that hydrogen and soot may also be unburned when CO is high.

Assumptions and limits

  • CO is the only unburned gas; hydrogen and hydrocarbons are not counted.
  • The gas quantity is computed with all carbon burned to CO₂ (the CO share is small). Above about 1 % CO the dry gas is noticeably understated and a warning appears.
  • Excess air must be the value at the CO sampling point, consistent with the O₂ the analyser reads there; use the excess air from O₂ calculator.
  • Air humidity changes only the wet flue gas; the dry gas quantity, and so every output here, does not depend on it.
  • A warning appears when the GCV differs from the Channiwala–Parikh estimate of the analysis by more than 15 %.

References

  • ASME PTC 4-2013 Fired Steam Generators §5.14 (CO loss)
  • BIS IS 8753 (boiler efficiency)

Questions and answers

How much efficiency does CO cost?

Less than most people think at normal readings. Coal at 25 % excess air with 300 ppm CO in dry flue gas loses 2.2 g of CO per kg of fuel, 0.28 % of the heat input. At 2000 ppm it is nearly 2 % and a sign of a combustion problem.

Why does the loss depend on the fuel and excess air?

The analyser gives a concentration; the loss needs the mass of CO per kg of fuel, which is that concentration times the dry flue gas per kg of fuel. More excess air means more gas, so the same ppm costs more.

What is 300 ppm in mg/Nm³?

About 375 mg/Nm³ dry, at 0 °C and 1.01325 bar. Emission limits are usually set at a reference O₂; correct the value with the O₂ correction calculator.

Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 10 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.

Related calculators

Free engineering calculators: every page computes in SI and converts to your units. Results are for engineering estimation; verify critical designs against the referenced standards.

Rejoining the server...

Rejoin failed... trying again in seconds.

Failed to rejoin.
Please retry or reload the page.

The session has been paused by the server.

Failed to resume the session.
Please retry or reload the page.