Worked example
Example: Ganapathy: 11,400 → 9,800 Btu/lb coal, 25 %. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Boiler duty | 30.000 MW |
| Efficiency (HHV) | 82.000 % |
| Fuel (Ganapathy Table 2.4: dry air per MMBtu fired, lb) | Bituminous coal (760) |
| New fuel, if of another class (0 = same as the design fuel) | Same as the design fuel |
| Excess air | 25.000 % |
| Design fuel heating value | 26.516 MJ/kg |
| New fuel heating value | 22.795 MJ/kg |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Design fuel burnt | 4.9670 t/h |
| New fuel burnt | 5.7780 t/h |
| Dry air, design fuel | 53.793 t/h |
| Dry air, new fuel | 53.793 t/h |
| Flue gas, design fuel | 58.760 t/h |
| Flue gas, new fuel | 59.571 t/h |
| Flue gas ratio | 1.0138 |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(W_f = \frac{Q_{out}}{\eta\,HHV}, \quad W_a = \frac{Q_{out}}{\eta}A_{SI}(1 + EA), \quad W_g = W_a + W_f\)
\(A_{SI}\) is \(A\) (lb/MMBtu) in kg/J; the new fuel uses \(A_2\) when a different class is chosen, otherwise \(A\).
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(Q_{out}\) | Boiler duty | W |
| \(\eta\) | Efficiency (HHV) | - |
| \(A\) | theoretical dry air per MMBtu fired, design fuel (Ganapathy Table 2.4) | lb/MMBtu |
| \(EA\) | Excess air | - |
| \(HHV_1\) | Design fuel heating value | J/kg |
| \(HHV_2\) | New fuel heating value | J/kg |
| \(W_{f1}\) | Design fuel burnt | kg/s |
| \(W_{f2}\) | New fuel burnt | kg/s |
| \(W_a\) | Dry air, design fuel | kg/s |
| \(A_2\) | air per MMBtu of the new fuel (0 = same as the design fuel) | lb/MMBtu |
| \(W_{a2}\) | Dry air, new fuel | kg/s |
| \(W_{g1}\) | Flue gas, design fuel | kg/s |
| \(W_{g2}\) | Flue gas, new fuel | kg/s |
| \(W_{g2}/W_{g1}\) | Flue gas ratio | - |
Method and standards
Ganapathy's MMBtu method applied to two fuels.
Where it is used
- Fuel switching studies.
- Coal procurement decisions.
Common mistakes
- Assuming the efficiency stays the same with a wetter fuel.
Assumptions and limits
- Same efficiency and excess air.
- The whole fuel mass, ash included, is added to the flue gas, as in Ganapathy's method; for a high-ash fuel the gas is slightly overstated.
- For a change of fuel class, choose the new fuel's air per MMBtu; otherwise the same value is used for both.
References
- Ganapathy
- Steam Plant Calculations Manual
- 2nd ed. (Marcel Dekker, 1993)
- Q2.14 and Table 2.4
Questions and answers
Why does air not change?
Air per unit of heat fired is nearly constant, so the same duty needs the same air.
Why does flue gas rise?
More fuel mass (moisture and ash) is burnt for the same heat.
What did Ganapathy find?
Switching from 11,400 to 9,800 Btu/lb coal raises flue gas by only about 1.5 %; fans can usually stay.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.