Worked example
Example: Ganapathy air heater, mode 1. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Tube natural frequency | 18.200 Hz |
| Tube outer diameter | 50.800 mm |
| Gas velocity in the gap | 6.4008 m/s |
| Strouhal number | 0.33000 - |
| Duct width across the gas flow and tubes | 3.5662 m |
| Gas temperature | 103.89 °C |
| Gas molar mass | 29.000 kg/kmol |
| Ratio of specific heats | 1.4000 - |
| Acoustic mode | 1.0000 - |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Vortex-shedding frequency | 41.580 Hz |
| Speed of sound | 389.02 m/s |
| Acoustic frequency | 54.544 Hz |
| Vortex / natural frequency | 2.2846 |
| Acoustic / vortex frequency | 1.3118 |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(f_v = \frac{S\,V}{d_o}, \quad c = \sqrt{\frac{\gamma R T}{M}}, \quad f_a = \frac{n\,c}{2W}\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(f_n\) | Tube natural frequency | 1/s |
| \(d_o\) | Tube outer diameter | m |
| \(V\) | Gas velocity in the gap | m/s |
| \(S\) | Strouhal number | - |
| \(W\) | Duct width across the gas flow and tubes | m |
| \(T\) | Gas temperature | K |
| \(M\) | Gas molar mass | kg/kmol |
| \(\gamma\) | Ratio of specific heats | - |
| \(n\) | Acoustic mode | - |
| \(f_v\) | Vortex-shedding frequency | 1/s |
| \(c\) | Speed of sound | m/s |
| \(f_a\) | Acoustic frequency | 1/s |
| \(f_v/f_n\) | Vortex / natural frequency | - |
| \(f_a/f_v\) | Acoustic / vortex frequency | - |
Method and standards
Ganapathy's checks with the ideal-gas speed of sound.
Where it is used
- Air heaters, economisers and HRSG bundles.
Common mistakes
- Using the approach velocity instead of the gap velocity.
- Checking only mode 1.
Assumptions and limits
The tube natural frequency f_n is an input: compute it from the tube span, end fixity, stiffness EI and mass per length (Ganapathy Q4.59 shows how) or take it from the maker.
One acoustic mode is checked at a time; repeat for modes 2, 3 … and compare each f_a with f_v. A direct comparison of f_a with f_n is not part of Ganapathy's check.
Strouhal number from charts for the pitch.
References
- Ganapathy
- Steam Plant Calculations Manual
- 2nd ed. (Marcel Dekker, 1993)
- Q4.59a–e (natural, vortex-shedding and acoustic frequencies; 20 % separation)
Questions and answers
Why three frequencies?
Tubes vibrate when vortex shedding matches their natural frequency; ducts drone when it matches a standing acoustic wave.
How are problems fixed?
Anti-vibration baffles parallel to the gas flow raise the acoustic frequency; supports raise the natural frequency.
What does Ganapathy's example find?
An air heater at 21 ft/s: f_v = 41.6 Hz against f_a = 54.5 Hz; a baffle doubles f_a to 109 Hz.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.