Worked example
Example: HRSG economiser: 50.8 mm tube, 88.9 mm fins, 1.2 mm, 4 mm pitch, h 60, steel 45. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Gas-side heat transfer coefficient | 60.000 W/(m²·K) |
| Fin thermal conductivity | 45.000 W/(m·K) |
| Fin thickness | 1.2000 mm |
| Tube outside diameter | 50.800 mm |
| Fin outside diameter | 88.900 mm |
| Fin pitch (centre to centre) | 4.0000 mm |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Fin efficiency | 72.368 % |
| Overall surface efficiency | 73.719 % |
| Total outside area per metre of tube | 2.2857 m² |
| Effective area per metre of tube | 1.6850 m² |
| Area ratio to the bare tube | 14.322 |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(m = \sqrt{\frac{2h}{k\,t}} \qquad \phi = \left(\frac{r_{ec}}{r_b} - 1\right)\left(1 + 0.35\ln\frac{r_{ec}}{r_b}\right) \qquad \eta_f = \frac{\tanh(m r_b \phi)}{m r_b \phi}\)
\(\eta_o = 1 - \frac{A_f}{A}(1 - \eta_f) \qquad A = A_f + A_b\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(h\) | gas-side coefficient | W/(m²·K) |
| \(k\) | fin conductivity | W/(m·K) |
| \(t\) | fin thickness | m |
| \(d_o\) | tube outside diameter | m |
| \(d_f\) | fin outside diameter | m |
| \(s\) | fin pitch | m |
| \(\eta_f\) | fin efficiency | – |
| \(\eta_o\) | overall surface efficiency | – |
| \(A\) | total area per metre | m² |
| \(\eta_o A\) | effective area per metre | m² |
| \(A/A_b\) | area ratio to bare tube | – |
| \(r_b\) | fin root radius | m |
| \(r_{ec}\) | fin tip radius plus half thickness | m |
| \(A_f\) | fin area per metre | m² |
| \(A_b\) | exposed tube area per metre | m² |
| \(m\) | fin parameter | 1/m |
| \(\phi\) | Schmidt geometry factor | – |
Method and standards
Schmidt's approximation for annular fins of constant thickness with the tip loss included by extending the radius by half the thickness; areas per metre of tube.
Where it is used
- HRSG and economiser design with finned tubes.
- Comparing fin heights, thicknesses and materials.
- Effective area for U and LMTD calculations.
Common mistakes
- Using the total finned area without the efficiency.
- Using serrated-fin data for solid fins.
- Ignoring fouling between closely spaced fins in dirty gas.
Assumptions and limits
- Solid annular fins of uniform thickness; uniform h; no contact resistance at the fin root.
- Serrated (segmented) fins, common in HRSGs, have a different efficiency and are not covered.
References
- T.E. Schmidt (1949) approximation for annular fins
Questions and answers
How efficient are economiser fins?
50.8 mm tubes with 88.9 mm steel fins 1.2 mm thick at 4 mm pitch, with a gas coefficient of 60 W/(m²·K), have a fin efficiency of 72 % and an overall surface efficiency of 74 %; each metre carries 2.29 m², 14 times the bare tube.
Why does fin efficiency fall?
Taller, thinner fins and higher gas coefficients make the fin tip much colder than its root, so the tip transfers less heat.
Stainless or carbon steel fins?
Stainless resists corrosion but conducts heat about three times worse, so its fins are less efficient at the same size.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 11 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.