Worked example
Example: Ganapathy Q8.47c: 590 tubes 2 in., 29.5 ft, 78 in. bundle, 400 psia (book F 0.15). The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Steam pressure (absolute) | 27.579 bar |
| Number of tubes | 590.00 - |
| Tube outside diameter | 50.800 mm |
| Tube length | 8.9916 m |
| Bundle diameter | 1,981.2 mm |
| Share of the corrected value allowed in design | 75.000 % |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Bundle surface area | 846.65 m² |
| Bundle factor D_bL/A | 0.021041 |
| Bundle correction factor | 0.15077 |
| Pool boiling critical heat flux (Mostinski) | 3,471.7 kW/m² |
| Bundle critical heat flux | 523.44 kW/m² |
| Allowable design flux | 392.58 kW/m² |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(C = \frac{D_bL}{A}, \quad \log F = 0.8452 + 0.994\log C, \quad F \le 1, \quad q_{c,bundle} = F\,q_{c,pool}, \quad q_{c,pool} = 803\,p_c\left(\frac{p}{p_c}\right)^{0.35}\left(1 - \frac{p}{p_c}\right)^{0.9}\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(p\) | Steam pressure (absolute) | Pa |
| \(N\) | Number of tubes | - |
| \(d_o\) | Tube outside diameter | m |
| \(L\) | Tube length | m |
| \(D_b\) | Bundle diameter | m |
| \(a\) | Share of the corrected value allowed in design | - |
| \(A\) | Bundle surface area | m² |
| \(C\) | Bundle factor D_bL/A | - |
| \(F\) | Bundle correction factor | - |
| \(q_{c,pool}\) | Pool boiling critical heat flux (Mostinski) | W/m² |
| \(q_{c,bundle}\) | Bundle critical heat flux | W/m² |
| \(q_{allow}\) | Allowable design flux | W/m² |
Method and standards
Mostinski with Ganapathy's bundle factor.
Where it is used
- Fire-tube waste heat boilers and kettle reboilers.
- Hydrogen plant reformed-gas boilers.
Common mistakes
- Comparing the average flux when the inlet flux is much higher.
- Using the single-tube value for a bundle.
Assumptions and limits
- Pool boiling of water outside horizontal tubes.
- The bundle factor F is capped at 1.
- US-unit correlation converted: p_c = 22.064 MPa = 3 200.1 psia, q in Btu/(ft²·h) × 3.154591 = W/m².
References
- Ganapathy
- Industrial Boilers and Heat Recovery Steam Generators (Marcel Dekker, 2003)
- Q8.47b–c (Mostinski pool boiling CHF and the bundle correction log F = 0.8452 + 0.994 log C)
Questions and answers
What does Ganapathy's example give?
590 tubes of 2 in., 29.5 ft long in a 78 in. bundle: C = 0.021, F = 0.15, so the bundle limit is about 166,000 Btu/(ft²·h) (162,500 in the book, which starts from the Zuber value) against about 1.1 million for a single tube.
Is a fire-tube boiler near this limit?
Rarely with flue gas (20,000–30,000 Btu/(ft²·h)); reformed-gas boilers in hydrogen plants can approach it.
Why use 70–80 % of the value?
To allow for fouling, water quality and uneven flux at the tube inlets.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.