Worked example
Example: Ganapathy: 2 in, 5 fins/in, solid CS. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Tube outer diameter | 50.800 mm |
| Average tube wall thickness | 3.0480 mm |
| Fin height | 19.050 mm |
| Fin thickness | 1.2700 mm |
| Fin density (fins per metre) | 196.85 - |
| Tube material factor (0 = same as the fins) | Same as the fins |
| Fin type | Solid |
| Fin material factor | Carbon steel and alloys (1.0) |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Fin mass per metre | 8.5229 kg/m |
| Tube mass per metre | 3.5856 kg/m |
| Finned tube mass per metre | 12.109 kg/m |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(W_f = 10.68\,F\,b\,n\,(d_o + h)(h + 0.03) \ \text{(solid)}, \quad W_f = 10.68\,F\,b\,n\,d_o(h + 0.12) \ \text{(serrated)}, \quad W_t = 10.68\,F_t\,d_m t_w \ \ (\mathrm{lb/ft};\ in)\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(d_o\) | Tube outer diameter | m |
| \(t_w\) | Average tube wall thickness | m |
| \(h\) | Fin height | m |
| \(b\) | Fin thickness | m |
| \(n\) | Fin density (fins per metre) | - |
| \(\text{type}\) | Fin type | - |
| \(F\) | Fin material factor | - |
| \(F_t\) | Tube material factor (0 = same as the fins) | - |
| \(W_f\) | Fin mass per metre | kg/m |
| \(W_t\) | Tube mass per metre | kg/m |
| \(W\) | Finned tube mass per metre | kg/m |
Method and standards
Ganapathy's Eqs. (64)–(65) converted to SI.
Where it is used
- HRSG and economiser weight estimates.
- Support and lifting design.
Common mistakes
- Entering fins per inch as fins per metre.
- Forgetting the tube itself.
Assumptions and limits
- Helical fins; steel density basis.
- Fins and tube may be of different materials (for example carbon-steel tube with stainless fins); with F_t = 0 the tube uses the fin factor.
References
- Ganapathy
- Steam Plant Calculations Manual
- 2nd ed. (Marcel Dekker, 1993)
- Q4.25
- Eqs. (64a)
- (64b)
- (65) and Table 4.20 (material factors)
Questions and answers
Why does fin width not matter for serrated fins?
Ganapathy's formula: the segment width does not change the mass, only the slit allowance (h + 0.12 in).
Where does 10.68 come from?
Steel density 0.283 lb/in³ times π times 12 in/ft.
What does Ganapathy's example give?
2 in tube, 5 fins/in, 0.75 in × 0.05 in solid fins: about 5.7 lb/ft of fins plus 2.4 lb/ft of tube.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.