FireCADCalc

Tube Bundle Vibration and Acoustic Resonance Check

Vortex-shedding and acoustic frequencies of a tube bundle in cross-flow, compared with the tube natural frequency by Ganapathy's 20 % separation rule.

Thermal power plantProcess steam and utilitiesSugar mill and cogenerationChemical and fertiliserPulp and paperBoilerEconomiser and air preheater

Inputs

Examples: Ganapathy air heater, mode 1Ganapathy air heater, mode 2 with baffle (half width)

Ganapathy Fig. 4.22: about 0.2–0.33 for common pitches.

Results

All three frequencies are at least 20 % apart in this mode; check other modes too.

Vortex-shedding frequency41.575Hz
Speed of sound388.94m/s
Acoustic frequency54.534Hz
Vortex / natural frequency2.2843
Acoustic / vortex frequency1.3117

Download PDF CSV Link to this result Compare another case

Log in to save calculations to your dashboard.

Worked example

Example: Ganapathy air heater, mode 1. The inputs, in the units selected above:

InputValue
Tube natural frequency18.200 Hz
Tube outer diameter50.800 mm
Gas velocity in the gap6.4008 m/s
Strouhal number0.33000 -
Duct width across the gas flow and tubes3.5662 m
Gas temperature103.89 °C
Gas molar mass29.000 kg/kmol
Ratio of specific heats1.4000 -
Acoustic mode1.0000 -

Applying the formula below gives:

ResultValue
Vortex-shedding frequency41.580 Hz
Speed of sound389.02 m/s
Acoustic frequency54.544 Hz
Vortex / natural frequency2.2846
Acoustic / vortex frequency1.3118

Open this example in the calculator and change any input.

Formula

\(f_v = \frac{S\,V}{d_o}, \quad c = \sqrt{\frac{\gamma R T}{M}}, \quad f_a = \frac{n\,c}{2W}\)

Variables

Symbol Meaning SI unit
\(f_n\) Tube natural frequency 1/s
\(d_o\) Tube outer diameter m
\(V\) Gas velocity in the gap m/s
\(S\) Strouhal number -
\(W\) Duct width across the gas flow and tubes m
\(T\) Gas temperature K
\(M\) Gas molar mass kg/kmol
\(\gamma\) Ratio of specific heats -
\(n\) Acoustic mode -
\(f_v\) Vortex-shedding frequency 1/s
\(c\) Speed of sound m/s
\(f_a\) Acoustic frequency 1/s
\(f_v/f_n\) Vortex / natural frequency -
\(f_a/f_v\) Acoustic / vortex frequency -

Method and standards

Ganapathy's checks with the ideal-gas speed of sound.

Where it is used

  • Air heaters, economisers and HRSG bundles.

Common mistakes

  • Using the approach velocity instead of the gap velocity.
  • Checking only mode 1.

Assumptions and limits

  • The tube natural frequency f_n is an input: compute it from the tube span, end fixity, stiffness EI and mass per length (Ganapathy Q4.59 shows how) or take it from the maker.

  • One acoustic mode is checked at a time; repeat for modes 2, 3 … and compare each f_a with f_v. A direct comparison of f_a with f_n is not part of Ganapathy's check.

  • Strouhal number from charts for the pitch.

References

  • Ganapathy
  • Steam Plant Calculations Manual
  • 2nd ed. (Marcel Dekker, 1993)
  • Q4.59a–e (natural, vortex-shedding and acoustic frequencies; 20 % separation)

Questions and answers

Why three frequencies?

Tubes vibrate when vortex shedding matches their natural frequency; ducts drone when it matches a standing acoustic wave.

How are problems fixed?

Anti-vibration baffles parallel to the gas flow raise the acoustic frequency; supports raise the natural frequency.

What does Ganapathy's example find?

An air heater at 21 ft/s: f_v = 41.6 Hz against f_a = 54.5 Hz; a baffle doubles f_a to 109 Hz.

Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.

Related calculators

Free engineering calculators: every page computes in SI and converts to your units. Results are for engineering estimation; verify critical designs against the referenced standards.

Rejoining the server...

Rejoin failed... trying again in seconds.

Failed to rejoin.
Please retry or reload the page.

The session has been paused by the server.

Failed to resume the session.
Please retry or reload the page.