FireCADCalc

Capacity of a Tandem with Mills of Different Sizes

Equivalent mill factor and crushing capacity of a tandem whose mills differ in size or speed, by Hugot's weighting (eqn 12.10) of the first mill and the rest.

Sugar mill and cogeneration

Inputs

Examples: Five mills of two sizesFour mills

Results

The first mill carries half the weight in Hugot's mean; the other mills share the rest equally. Factors in rpm·m³; the capacity formula gives t/h, converted here.

Number of mills5.0000
First-mill factor n(1 − 0.06nD)LD²5.5449
Equivalent mill factor5.2289
Crushing capacity153.35t/h

Download PDF CSV Link to this result Compare another case

Log in to save calculations to your dashboard.

Worked example

Example: Five mills of two sizes. The inputs, in the units selected above:

InputValue
Cane preparationTwo knife sets and a shredder (1.22)
Total rollers in the tandem15.000 -
Fibre % cane14.500 %
Mill 1: roller diameter0.91400 m
Mill 1: roller length (0 if no mill)1.8290 m
Mill 1: speed5.0000 rpm
Mill 2: roller diameter0.86400 m
Mill 2: roller length (0 if no mill)1.6760 m
Mill 2: speed5.5000 rpm
Mill 3: roller diameter0.86400 m
Mill 3: roller length (0 if no mill)1.6760 m
Mill 3: speed5.5000 rpm
Mill 4: roller diameter0.86400 m
Mill 4: roller length (0 if no mill)1.6760 m
Mill 4: speed5.0000 rpm
Mill 5: roller diameter0.91400 m
Mill 5: roller length (0 if no mill)1.8290 m
Mill 5: speed4.5000 rpm
Mill 6: roller diameter0.91400 m
Mill 6: roller length (0 if no mill)0 m
Mill 6: speed4.5000 rpm

Applying the formula below gives:

ResultValue
Number of mills5.0000
First-mill factor n(1 − 0.06nD)LD²5.5449
Equivalent mill factor5.2289
Crushing capacity153.35 t/h

Open this example in the calculator and change any input.

Formula

\(G_i = n_i(1 - 0.06\,n_iD_i)L_iD_i^2, \quad G_m = \frac{(N_1 - 1)G_1 + G_2 + \dots + G_{N_1}}{2(N_1 - 1)}, \quad A = \frac{0.9\,c\,G_m\sqrt N}{f}\)

Variables

Symbol Meaning SI unit
\(c\) Cane preparation -
\(N\) Total rollers in the tandem -
\(f\) Fibre % cane -
\(D_1\) Mill 1: roller diameter m
\(L_1\) Mill 1: roller length (0 if no mill) m
\(n_1\) Mill 1: speed 1/s
\(D_2\) Mill 2: roller diameter m
\(L_2\) Mill 2: roller length (0 if no mill) m
\(n_2\) Mill 2: speed 1/s
\(D_3\) Mill 3: roller diameter m
\(L_3\) Mill 3: roller length (0 if no mill) m
\(n_3\) Mill 3: speed 1/s
\(D_4\) Mill 4: roller diameter m
\(L_4\) Mill 4: roller length (0 if no mill) m
\(n_4\) Mill 4: speed 1/s
\(D_5\) Mill 5: roller diameter m
\(L_5\) Mill 5: roller length (0 if no mill) m
\(n_5\) Mill 5: speed 1/s
\(D_6\) Mill 6: roller diameter m
\(L_6\) Mill 6: roller length (0 if no mill) m
\(n_6\) Mill 6: speed 1/s
\(N_1\) Number of mills -
\(G_1\) First-mill factor n(1 − 0.06nD)LD² -
\(G_m\) Equivalent mill factor -
\(A\) Crushing capacity kg/s

Method and standards

Hugot's weighted mean mill factor in his capacity formula.

Where it is used

  • Rating tandems rebuilt with mills of several sizes.
  • Judging which mill limits capacity.

Common mistakes

  • Leaving a non-existent mill with a non-zero length.
  • Counting crusher rollers in N₁.

Assumptions and limits

  • Hugot's empirical formula, with n in rpm, L and D in metres and A in t/h (the page converts from SI).
  • Mills are listed in order without gaps, and the total rollers N must be at least three per mill entered (extra rollers for a crusher or feed rollers are allowed).

References

  • Hugot
  • Handbook of Cane Sugar Engineering
  • 3rd ed. (Elsevier, 1986)
  • ch. 12
  • eqns 12.6 and 12.10
  • pp. 191–195

Questions and answers

Why weight the first mill so heavily?

The first mill sets the feed for the whole tandem; Hugot gives it half the weight and the others the other half.

Speeds in rpm?

Yes, the factor G uses rpm and metres as in Hugot's formula.

Can I enter five mills?

Yes: set the length of unused mills to 0; mill 1 must be present.

Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.

Related calculators

Free engineering calculators: every page computes in SI and converts to your units. Results are for engineering estimation; verify critical designs against the referenced standards.

Rejoining the server...

Rejoin failed... trying again in seconds.

Failed to rejoin.
Please retry or reload the page.

The session has been paused by the server.

Failed to resume the session.
Please retry or reload the page.