Worked example
Example: Steam main DN150 (168.3 mm) at 180 °C, wool 0.045, 8 000 h. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Pipe outer diameter | 168.30 mm |
| Insulation thermal conductivity | 0.045000 W/(m·K) |
| Pipe (process) temperature | 180.00 °C |
| Ambient temperature | 30.000 °C |
| Emissivity of the cladding | 0.10000 - |
| Operating hours per year | 8,000.0 h |
| Cost of heat in fuel, per kWh (your currency) | 2.5000 - |
| Efficiency of the heat supply (boiler) | 85.000 % |
| Installed insulation cost per m³ (your currency) | 40,000 - |
| Interest rate | 10.000 % |
| Life of the insulation, years | 10.000 - |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Economic insulation thickness | 98.484 mm |
| Heat loss per metre at that thickness | 50.360 W/m |
| Yearly cost of heat lost, per metre | 1,184.9 |
| Yearly cost of the insulation, per metre | 537.33 |
| Total yearly cost per metre | 1,722.3 |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(C_t(t) = \frac{q'(t)\, t_y}{\eta_b} c_h + CRF \cdot c_i \frac{\pi}{4}\left[(D_o + 2t)^2 - D_o^2\right]\)
\(CRF = \frac{i (1+i)^n}{(1+i)^n - 1}\)
\(t_{opt} = \arg\min C_t(t)\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(D_o\) | pipe outer diameter | m |
| \(\lambda\) | insulation thermal conductivity | W/(m·K) |
| \(T_i\) | pipe temperature | K |
| \(T_a\) | ambient temperature | K |
| \(\varepsilon\) | cladding emissivity | - |
| \(t_y\) | operating hours per year | s |
| \(c_h\) | cost of heat in fuel per kWh | currency/kWh |
| \(\eta_b\) | efficiency of the heat supply | - |
| \(c_i\) | installed insulation cost per m³ | currency/m³ |
| \(i\) | interest rate | - |
| \(n\) | insulation life | years |
| \(t\) | insulation thickness | m |
| \(q'\) | heat loss per metre (ISO 12241) | W/m |
| \(CRF\) | capital recovery factor | 1/year |
| \(t_{opt}\) | economic thickness | m |
| \(C_h\) | yearly heat cost per metre | currency/(m·year) |
| \(C_i\) | yearly insulation cost per metre | currency/(m·year) |
| \(C_t\) | total yearly cost per metre | currency/(m·year) |
Method and standards
Heat loss per metre for each thickness is found by ISO 12241 (conduction through the insulation, natural convection and radiation from the cladding). The yearly heat cost uses the hours, the heat price and the supply efficiency; the insulation is annualised with the capital recovery factor. A golden-section search finds the thickness with the lowest total.
Where it is used
- Specifying insulation thickness for new steam, condensate and hot water lines.
- Justifying re-insulation of old or damaged lagging.
- Comparing insulation materials on cost.
Common mistakes
- Using installed cost per m² instead of per m³.
- Forgetting the boiler efficiency when pricing lost heat.
- Ignoring the safe surface temperature, which can need more than the economic thickness.
Assumptions and limits
- Horizontal pipe in still air (ISO 12241).
- Insulation cost proportional to volume.
- Single layer; constant prices over the life.
- Insulation cost proportional to volume, with no fixed cladding or labour cost per metre (a fixed cost does not move the optimum but adds to the total).
- No inside film or pipe-wall resistance: the pipe surface is taken at the process temperature (slightly conservative).
References
- ISO 12241 heat loss
- Capital recovery factor
Questions and answers
What is the economic insulation thickness for a 150 mm steam main at 180 °C?
About 98 mm of mineral wool in the example (heat at 2.5 per kWh, insulation at 40 000 per m³ installed, 10 % over 10 years).
Why is there an optimum?
More insulation cuts the heat lost, but each extra millimetre covers a larger area and saves less; at the optimum the last millimetre costs as much as it saves.
Should I round up or down?
Up: the total cost curve is flat near the optimum, and a thicker layer protects against rising fuel prices.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 12 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.