Worked example
Example: Sand in water, DN150, 15 %. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Pipe inside diameter | 154.10 mm |
| Solid density | 2,650.0 kg/m³ |
| Liquid density | 998.00 kg/m³ |
| Solids volume fraction | 15.000 % |
| Durand factor F_L (1.5 conservative) | 1.5000 - |
| Particle size (85 % by mass smaller) | 0.50000 mm |
| Liquid viscosity | 1.0000 cP |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Slurry density | 1,245.8 kg/m³ |
| Minimum transport (deposition) velocity | 3.3551 m/s |
| Flow at the minimum velocity | 225.27 m³/h |
| Velocity for symmetric suspension (Spells) | 5.2181 m/s |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(V_{M2} = F_L\sqrt{2gD(s - 1)}, \quad V_{M1}^2 = 0.075\left(\frac{DV_{M1}\rho_M}{\mu}\right)^{0.775}gD_S(s - 1), \quad s = \frac{\rho_S}{\rho_L}\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(D\) | Pipe inside diameter | m |
| \(\rho_S\) | Solid density | kg/m³ |
| \(\rho_L\) | Liquid density | kg/m³ |
| \(C_S\) | Solids volume fraction | - |
| \(F_L\) | Durand factor F_L (1.5 conservative) | - |
| \(D_S\) | Particle size (85 % by mass smaller) | m |
| \(\mu\) | Liquid viscosity | Pa·s |
| \(\rho_M\) | Slurry density | kg/m³ |
| \(V_{M2}\) | Minimum transport (deposition) velocity | m/s |
| \(Q_{min}\) | Flow at the minimum velocity | m³/s |
| \(V_{M1}\) | Velocity for symmetric suspension (Spells) | m/s |
Method and standards
Durand and Spells correlations.
Where it is used
- Ash slurry disposal lines.
- Lime, sand and mineral slurries.
Common mistakes
- Using it for non-settling (fine, concentrated) slurries.
- Designing at the deposition velocity with no margin.
Assumptions and limits
- Settling slurries in horizontal pipes.
- The two velocities answer different questions: V_M2 (Durand) is the limit below which a stationary deposit forms; V_M1 (Spells) is the velocity for full, symmetric suspension. They can differ widely (in the fly-ash preset Spells gives 1.39 m/s and Durand 2.45 m/s). Design above V_M2 with a margin; where V_M1 is the larger, run near it only if a fully suspended profile is needed, since wear rises with velocity.
References
- Perry's Chemical Engineers' Handbook
- 9th ed. (McGraw-Hill, 2019)
- sec. 6
- Eqs. (6-150) (Durand) and (6-152) (Spells)
Questions and answers
What happens below the deposition velocity?
Solids settle and form a bed; pressure gradient rises sharply and the line can block.
What F_L should I use?
Durand's chart gives 0.4–1.5 by particle size and concentration; 1.5 is the conservative design value Perry's quotes.
Is a higher velocity always better?
No: wear rises steeply with velocity. Aim a little above V_M2.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.