FireCADCalc

Pan Calandria: Optimum Downtake and Tube Count (Hugot)

Downtake diameter for best circulation in a calandria pan by Hugot's formula (eqns 33.26–33.27), tube count, heating surface and his working volume rule V = 1.9Δ².

Sugar mill and cogeneration

Inputs

Examples: 4 m pan, 101.6 mm tubesHugot Table 33.4 case k 0.5

Hugot: 0.70–0.80.

Results

Hugot's Table 33.4 check: k = 0.5 and d/Δ = 0.03 give m ≈ 0.30. He adds a tenth of (1 − m) for scale and the cone of the bottom.

The pitch is checked against the inside diameter only: make sure it also leaves a sound ligament over the tube outside diameter.

Tube-plate coefficient k₁k₂45.632%
Optimum downtake / pan diameter29.647%
Practical ratio m + (1 − m)/1036.682%
Downtake diameter1.1922m
Number of tubes438.00
Heating surface160.99m²
Working volume 1.9Δ² (Δ in m)20.069m³
Surface / volume (m²/m³)8.0221

Download PDF CSV Link to this result Compare another case

Log in to save calculations to your dashboard.

Worked example

Example: 4 m pan, 101.6 mm tubes. The inputs, in the units selected above:

InputValue
Pan (calandria) diameter4.0000 m
Tube inside diameter97.400 mm
Tube pitch127.00 mm
Share of the plate filled with tubes75.000 %
Tube length1.0000 m

Applying the formula below gives:

ResultValue
Tube-plate coefficient k₁k₂40.007 %
Optimum downtake / pan diameter27.201 %
Practical ratio m + (1 − m)/1034.481 %
Downtake diameter1.3792 m
Number of tubes594.00
Heating surface181.76 m²
Working volume 1.9Δ² (Δ in m)30.400 m³
Surface / volume (m²/m³)5.9789

Open this example in the calculator and change any input.

Formula

\(k = \frac{\pi}{2\sqrt3}\frac{d^2}{p_t^2}k_2, \quad m = \sqrt[3]{p\sqrt{2k}} - \frac{p\sqrt{2k}}{3}\ (p = d/\Delta), \quad M' = m + \frac{1 - m}{10}\)

\(n = \frac{k(1 - M'^2)}{p^2}, \quad S = n\pi d\ell, \quad V = 1.9\Delta^2\)

Variables

Symbol Meaning SI unit
\(\Delta\) Pan (calandria) diameter m
\(d\) Tube inside diameter m
\(p_t\) Tube pitch m
\(k_2\) Share of the plate filled with tubes -
\(\ell\) Tube length m
\(k\) Tube-plate coefficient k₁k₂ -
\(m\) Optimum downtake / pan diameter -
\(M'\) Practical ratio m + (1 − m)/10 -
\(D\) Downtake diameter m
\(n\) Number of tubes -
\(S\) Heating surface m²
\(V\) Working volume 1.9Δ² (Δ in m) m³
\(S/V\) Surface / volume (m²/m³) 1/m

Method and standards

Hugot's analysis of natural circulation in pans.

Where it is used

  • Designing calandria pans.
  • Checking pans for poor circulation.

Common mistakes

  • Using outside tube diameter for d.
  • Too small a downtake for low-grade pans.

Assumptions and limits

  • Natural circulation; vertical tubes.
  • The pitch is checked only against the inside diameter; check the ligament over the outside diameter separately.
  • V = 1.9Δ² is dimensional: Δ in metres gives V in m³. S/V is in m²/m³ and shown as a plain number.

References

  • Hugot
  • Handbook of Cane Sugar Engineering
  • 3rd ed. (Elsevier, 1986)
  • ch. 33
  • eqns 33.6–33.15 and 33.24–33.27
  • pp. 640–653

Questions and answers

Why is the downtake so important?

Massecuite circulates up the tubes and down the well; Hugot balances the friction in both to maximise flow.

Why larger than the theoretical optimum?

Scale, viscosity and the shape of the bottom favour a slightly bigger well.

Where does V = 1.9Δ² come from?

Hugot's relation between useful capacity and diameter for normal heights over the calandria.

Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.

Related calculators

Free engineering calculators: every page computes in SI and converts to your units. Results are for engineering estimation; verify critical designs against the referenced standards.

Rejoining the server...

Rejoin failed... trying again in seconds.

Failed to rejoin.
Please retry or reload the page.

The session has been paused by the server.

Failed to resume the session.
Please retry or reload the page.