Worked example
Example: 4 m pan, 101.6 mm tubes. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Pan (calandria) diameter | 4.0000 m |
| Tube inside diameter | 97.400 mm |
| Tube pitch | 127.00 mm |
| Share of the plate filled with tubes | 75.000 % |
| Tube length | 1.0000 m |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Tube-plate coefficient k₁k₂ | 40.007 % |
| Optimum downtake / pan diameter | 27.201 % |
| Practical ratio m + (1 − m)/10 | 34.481 % |
| Downtake diameter | 1.3792 m |
| Number of tubes | 594.00 |
| Heating surface | 181.76 m² |
| Working volume 1.9Δ² (Δ in m) | 30.400 m³ |
| Surface / volume (m²/m³) | 5.9789 |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(k = \frac{\pi}{2\sqrt3}\frac{d^2}{p_t^2}k_2, \quad m = \sqrt[3]{p\sqrt{2k}} - \frac{p\sqrt{2k}}{3}\ (p = d/\Delta), \quad M' = m + \frac{1 - m}{10}\)
\(n = \frac{k(1 - M'^2)}{p^2}, \quad S = n\pi d\ell, \quad V = 1.9\Delta^2\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(\Delta\) | Pan (calandria) diameter | m |
| \(d\) | Tube inside diameter | m |
| \(p_t\) | Tube pitch | m |
| \(k_2\) | Share of the plate filled with tubes | - |
| \(\ell\) | Tube length | m |
| \(k\) | Tube-plate coefficient k₁k₂ | - |
| \(m\) | Optimum downtake / pan diameter | - |
| \(M'\) | Practical ratio m + (1 − m)/10 | - |
| \(D\) | Downtake diameter | m |
| \(n\) | Number of tubes | - |
| \(S\) | Heating surface | m² |
| \(V\) | Working volume 1.9Δ² (Δ in m) | m³ |
| \(S/V\) | Surface / volume (m²/m³) | 1/m |
Method and standards
Hugot's analysis of natural circulation in pans.
Where it is used
- Designing calandria pans.
- Checking pans for poor circulation.
Common mistakes
- Using outside tube diameter for d.
- Too small a downtake for low-grade pans.
Assumptions and limits
- Natural circulation; vertical tubes.
- The pitch is checked only against the inside diameter; check the ligament over the outside diameter separately.
- V = 1.9Δ² is dimensional: Δ in metres gives V in m³. S/V is in m²/m³ and shown as a plain number.
References
- Hugot
- Handbook of Cane Sugar Engineering
- 3rd ed. (Elsevier, 1986)
- ch. 33
- eqns 33.6–33.15 and 33.24–33.27
- pp. 640–653
Questions and answers
Why is the downtake so important?
Massecuite circulates up the tubes and down the well; Hugot balances the friction in both to maximise flow.
Why larger than the theoretical optimum?
Scale, viscosity and the shape of the bottom favour a slightly bigger well.
Where does V = 1.9Δ² come from?
Hugot's relation between useful capacity and diameter for normal heights over the calandria.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.