FireCADCalc

Comparative Work Index (Berry and Bruce Method)

Work index of a test ore by grinding it for the same time as a reference ore of known work index (Berry and Bruce comparative method), with both size reductions.

Inputs

Examples: Reference 13.0 kWh/t ore, test ore ground coarserSoft test ore ground finerSame feed size

Results

Valid when the two ores are ground to similar product size distributions in the same mill, for the same time, with equal masses (Wills).

Work index of the test ore9.7481kWh/t
Energy input (same for both)7.1147kWh/t
Hardness relative to the reference0.81234

Download PDF CSV Link to this result Compare another case

Log in to save calculations to your dashboard.

Worked example

Example: Reference 13.0 kWh/t ore, test ore ground coarser. The inputs, in the units selected above:

InputValue
Work index of the reference ore13.000 kWh/t
Reference feed 80 % passing1,700.0 µm
Reference product 80 % passing140.00 µm
Test ore feed 80 % passing1,750.0 µm
Test ore product 80 % passing165.00 µm

Applying the formula below gives:

ResultValue
Work index of the test ore14.522 kWh/t
Energy input (same for both)7.8340 kWh/t
Hardness relative to the reference1.1171

Open this example in the calculator and change any input.

Formula

\(W_{it} = W_{ir}\frac{10/\sqrt{P_{80r}} - 10/\sqrt{F_{80r}}}{10/\sqrt{P_{80t}} - 10/\sqrt{F_{80t}}}\)

Variables

Symbol Meaning SI unit
\(W_{ir}\) Work index of the reference ore J/kg
\(F_{80r}\) Reference feed 80 % passing m
\(P_{80r}\) Reference product 80 % passing m
\(F_{80t}\) Test ore feed 80 % passing m
\(P_{80t}\) Test ore product 80 % passing m
\(W_{it}\) Work index of the test ore J/kg
\(W\) Energy input (same for both) J/kg
\(W_{it}/W_{ir}\) Hardness relative to the reference -

Method and standards

Equal energy in Bond's equation for both ores.

Where it is used

  • Ore variability programmes.
  • Checking a laboratory work index.

Common mistakes

  • Grinding different masses of the two ores.
  • Using a reference ore of unknown index.

Assumptions and limits

  • Same mill, time and mass for both ores.

References

  • Wills and Finch
  • Wills' Mineral Processing Technology
  • 8th ed. (Butterworth-Heinemann, 2016)
  • ch. 5
  • eq. 5.8 (Berry and Bruce, 1966)

Questions and answers

Why not run the full Bond test?

The locked-cycle Bond test is slow; the comparative test needs one batch grind of each ore and a reference ore of known index.

What limits its accuracy?

The two products must have similar size distributions; very different ores break differently.

What do the defaults represent?

A reference ore of 13.0 kWh/t ground from 1,700 to 140 µm; the test ore went from 1,750 to 165 µm in the same time.

Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 17 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.

Related calculators

Free engineering calculators: every page computes in SI and converts to your units. Results are for engineering estimation; verify critical designs against the referenced standards.

Rejoining the server...

Rejoin failed... trying again in seconds.

Failed to rejoin.
Please retry or reload the page.

The session has been paused by the server.

Failed to resume the session.
Please retry or reload the page.