Worked example
Example: Sugar mill 20 MW power, 60 MW process heat, 110 MW fuel. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Net electrical output | 20.000 MW |
| Useful heat delivered to process | 60.000 MW |
| Fuel heat input | 110.00 MW |
| Reference efficiency of separate power generation | 45.000 % |
| Reference efficiency of separate heat (boiler) | 90.000 % |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Heat-to-power ratio | 3.0000 |
| Energy utilisation factor (overall efficiency) | 72.727 % |
| Electrical efficiency | 18.182 % |
| Thermal (heat) efficiency | 54.545 % |
| Primary energy saving against separate production | 1.00000 % |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(\frac{Q}{P} \qquad EUF = \frac{P + Q}{F} \qquad \eta_e = \frac{P}{F} \qquad \eta_h = \frac{Q}{F}\)
\(PES = 1 - \frac{1}{\dfrac{\eta_h}{\eta_{ref,h}} + \dfrac{\eta_e}{\eta_{ref,e}}}\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(P\) | net electrical output | W |
| \(Q\) | useful heat delivered | W |
| \(F\) | fuel heat input | W |
| \(\eta_{ref,e}\) | reference efficiency of separate power | – |
| \(\eta_{ref,h}\) | reference efficiency of separate heat | – |
| \(Q/P\) | heat-to-power ratio | – |
| \(EUF\) | energy utilisation factor | – |
| \(\eta_e\) | electrical efficiency | – |
| \(\eta_h\) | thermal efficiency | – |
| \(PES\) | primary energy saving | – |
Method and standards
Standard cogeneration ratios; primary energy saving by the formula of Directive 2012/27/EU Annex II, with the reference efficiencies entered by you. The Directive applies the formula to the cogeneration part of the plant only (electricity from cogeneration found by its Annex I, with harmonised reference values and correction factors). Here it is applied to the totals you enter, so for a plant with a condensing tail or bypass it overstates PES unless you enter the cogeneration part alone.
Where it is used
- Feasibility of cogeneration in sugar, paper, chemical and food plants.
- Qualifying a plant as high-efficiency cogeneration where a PES threshold applies.
- Comparing steam-turbine, gas-engine and gas-turbine CHP options.
Common mistakes
- Counting heat that is dumped (to a cooling tower) as useful heat.
- Mixing gross and net calorific value in the fuel input. The EU reference efficiencies are on the net (NCV) basis, so a fuel input on the gross basis understates PES.
- Comparing EUF figures of plants that sell power and heat at very different values: a kWh is worth more than a kWh of heat.
Assumptions and limits
- Annual or steady-state totals in one consistent basis; useful heat only.
References
- Directive 2012/27/EU Annex II (primary energy savings formula)
- standard cogeneration definitions
Questions and answers
What is a good heat-to-power ratio?
It should match the site. Back-pressure steam cogeneration runs at 3–10, gas engines about 1, gas turbines with heat recovery 1.3–2. A sugar mill making 20 MW and 60 MW of process heat has a ratio of 3.
What is the energy utilisation factor?
Power plus useful heat over fuel input. The sugar mill burning 110 MW of fuel uses 72.7 % of it; a condensing power station uses 35–45 %.
What reference efficiencies should I use for PES?
The reference values that apply in your country for the fuel and the plant's year; the EU publishes them in a delegated regulation. The defaults here are placeholders for you to replace.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 11 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.