Worked example
Example: Ganapathy: three superheater passes, 15,000 lb/h. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Total flow | 6,803.9 kg/h |
| Tube 1 inner diameter | 50.800 mm |
| Tube 1 equivalent length | 121.92 m |
| Tube 1 friction factor | 0.019500 - |
| Tube 2 inner diameter | 44.450 mm |
| Tube 2 equivalent length | 106.68 m |
| Tube 2 friction factor | 0.020000 - |
| Tube 3 inner diameter (0 = none) | 50.800 mm |
| Tube 3 equivalent length | 112.78 m |
| Tube 3 friction factor | 0.019500 - |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Flow in tube 1 | 2,433.7 kg/h |
| Flow in tube 2 | 1,839.8 kg/h |
| Flow in tube 3 | 2,530.4 kg/h |
| Lowest flow relative to the mean | 81.123 % |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(\Delta p \propto \frac{f L W^2}{d^5} \Rightarrow W_i = W\frac{\sqrt{d_i^5/(f_iL_i)}}{\sum_j\sqrt{d_j^5/(f_jL_j)}}, \quad \frac{W_{min}}{\bar W} = \frac{n\,\min_i W_i}{W}\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(W\) | Total flow | kg/s |
| \(d_1\) | Tube 1 inner diameter | m |
| \(L_1\) | Tube 1 equivalent length | m |
| \(f_1\) | Tube 1 friction factor | - |
| \(d_2\) | Tube 2 inner diameter | m |
| \(L_2\) | Tube 2 equivalent length | m |
| \(f_2\) | Tube 2 friction factor | - |
| \(d_3\) | Tube 3 inner diameter (0 = none) | m |
| \(L_3\) | Tube 3 equivalent length | m |
| \(f_3\) | Tube 3 friction factor | - |
| \(W_1\) | Flow in tube 1 | kg/s |
| \(W_2\) | Flow in tube 2 | kg/s |
| \(W_3\) | Flow in tube 3 | kg/s |
| \(W_{min}/\bar W\) | Lowest flow relative to the mean | - |
| \(n\) | number of tubes (2, or 3 when d_3 > 0) | - |
Method and standards
Equal pressure drop in parallel passes.
Where it is used
- Superheater and reheater design.
- Economiser and furnace circuit checks.
Common mistakes
- Ignoring header pressure gradients.
- Using actual instead of equivalent length.
Assumptions and limits
- Same fluid properties in all tubes; header pressure drop neglected. In a superheater the low-flow tube runs hotter, so its steam is lighter and its pressure drop per kg higher, which cuts its flow further: the split found here is optimistic for the worst tube.
References
- Ganapathy
- Steam Plant Calculations Manual
- 2nd ed. (Marcel Dekker, 1993)
- Q3.25 (flow in parallel passes of a superheater)
- Darcy pressure drop Δp ∝ f L W²/d⁵ at equal properties
Questions and answers
Why do parallel tubes share flow unequally?
Each tube must have the same header-to-header pressure drop, so longer or smaller tubes carry less.
Why does it matter?
The tube with least steam runs hottest; a superheater can fail there first.
What did Ganapathy find?
Three tubes sharing 15,000 lb/h took about 5,350, 4,050 and 5,590 lb/h.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.