FireCADCalc

Evaporator Performance Check (Hugot's Method)

Dessin factor achieved by each effect of a working 3- to 5-effect evaporator from juice and syrup brix, bleeds, surfaces and temperatures (Hugot pp. 600–602).

Sugar mill and cogeneration

Inputs

Examples: Hugot example: 98 TCH quadrupleTriple check

Results

Hugot: factors near 0.001 are good; equal low factors in all effects point to scale, one low effect to a fault (scale, leak, gas or juice level).

Total evaporation47,000kg/h
Surface of effect 1 used to heat the juice 0.1 Q(t₁ − t₀)52.800m²
Evaporation of effect 119,667kg/h
Evaporation of effect 213,667kg/h
Evaporation of effect 313,667kg/h
Evaporation of effect 40kg/h
Evaporation of effect 50kg/h
Dessin factor achieved by effect 15.7999e-04
Dessin factor achieved by effect 24.6431e-04
Dessin factor achieved by effect 35.6599e-04
Dessin factor achieved by effect 40
Dessin factor achieved by effect 50

Download PDF CSV Link to this result Compare another case

Log in to save calculations to your dashboard.

Worked example

Example: Hugot example: 98 TCH quadruple. The inputs, in the units selected above:

InputValue
Clear juice to the evaporator94.080 t/h
Clear juice brix14.000 %
Syrup brix56.000 %
Juice temperature entering effect 196.000 °C
Number of effects4.0000 -
Heating steam temperature (effect 1)115.00 °C
Vapour temperature leaving effect 1105.00 °C
Vapour temperature leaving effect 294.000 °C
Vapour temperature leaving effect 381.000 °C
Vapour temperature leaving effect 454.000 °C
Vapour temperature leaving effect 554.000 °C
Boiling-point rise in effect 1 (brix and head)1.0000 K
Boiling-point rise in effect 2 (brix and head)1.5000 K
Boiling-point rise in effect 3 (brix and head)2.0000 K
Boiling-point rise in effect 4 (brix and head)5.7000 K
Boiling-point rise in effect 5 (brix and head)5.7000 K
Vapour bled from effect 110,000 kg/h
Vapour bled from effect 25,000.0 kg/h
Vapour bled from effect 30 kg/h
Vapour bled from effect 40 kg/h
Heating surface of effect 11,000.0 m²
Heating surface of effect 2700.00 m²
Heating surface of effect 3600.00 m²
Heating surface of effect 4550.00 m²
Heating surface of effect 5500.00 m²

Applying the formula below gives:

ResultValue
Total evaporation70,560 kg/h
Surface of effect 1 used to heat the juice 0.1 Q(t₁ − t₀)94.080 m²
Evaporation of effect 127,640 kg/h
Evaporation of effect 217,640 kg/h
Evaporation of effect 312,640 kg/h
Evaporation of effect 412,640 kg/h
Evaporation of effect 50 kg/h
Dessin factor achieved by effect 16.6886e-04
Dessin factor achieved by effect 26.7908e-04
Dessin factor achieved by effect 37.0108e-04
Dessin factor achieved by effect 47.4295e-04
Dessin factor achieved by effect 50

Open this example in the calculator and change any input.

Formula

\(E = J\left(1 - \frac{B_0}{B_s}\right), \quad x = \frac{E - \sum_{i<n} i P_i}{n}, \quad q_i = x + \sum_{k=i}^{n-1} P_k\)

\(s_1 = 0.1\,J\,(T_1 + d_1 - t_0), \quad \Delta_i = T_{i-1} - T_i - d_i, \quad f_i = \frac{q_i}{(100 - \bar b_i)(T_{i-1} - 54)(S_i - s_1\,[i = 1])\,\Delta_i}\)

\(b_i = \frac{100\,B_0 J}{J - \sum_{k\le i} q_k}, \quad \bar b_i = \frac{b_{i-1} + b_i}{2}\)

Variables

Symbol Meaning SI unit
\(J\) Clear juice to the evaporator kg/s
\(B_0\) Clear juice brix -
\(B_s\) Syrup brix -
\(t_0\) Juice temperature entering effect 1 K
\(n\) Number of effects -
\(T_0\) Heating steam temperature (effect 1) K
\(T_1\) Vapour temperature leaving effect 1 K
\(T_2\) Vapour temperature leaving effect 2 K
\(T_3\) Vapour temperature leaving effect 3 K
\(T_4\) Vapour temperature leaving effect 4 K
\(T_5\) Vapour temperature leaving effect 5 K
\(d_1\) Boiling-point rise in effect 1 (brix and head) K
\(d_2\) Boiling-point rise in effect 2 (brix and head) K
\(d_3\) Boiling-point rise in effect 3 (brix and head) K
\(d_4\) Boiling-point rise in effect 4 (brix and head) K
\(d_5\) Boiling-point rise in effect 5 (brix and head) K
\(P_1\) Vapour bled from effect 1 kg/s
\(P_2\) Vapour bled from effect 2 kg/s
\(P_3\) Vapour bled from effect 3 kg/s
\(P_4\) Vapour bled from effect 4 kg/s
\(S_1\) Heating surface of effect 1 m²
\(S_2\) Heating surface of effect 2 m²
\(S_3\) Heating surface of effect 3 m²
\(S_4\) Heating surface of effect 4 m²
\(S_5\) Heating surface of effect 5 m²
\(E\) Total evaporation kg/s
\(s_1\) Surface of effect 1 used to heat the juice 0.1 Q(t₁ − t₀) m²
\(q_1\) Evaporation of effect 1 kg/s
\(q_2\) Evaporation of effect 2 kg/s
\(q_3\) Evaporation of effect 3 kg/s
\(q_4\) Evaporation of effect 4 kg/s
\(q_5\) Evaporation of effect 5 kg/s
\(f_1\) Dessin factor achieved by effect 1 -
\(f_2\) Dessin factor achieved by effect 2 -
\(f_3\) Dessin factor achieved by effect 3 -
\(f_4\) Dessin factor achieved by effect 4 -
\(f_5\) Dessin factor achieved by effect 5 -
\(x\) Evaporation each effect would give with no bleeding kg/s
\(\Delta_i\) Net temperature drop of effect i K
\(b_i, \bar b_i\) Brix leaving effect i and mean brix in it (%) -

Method and standards

Hugot's performance check with Dessin's formula.

Where it is used

  • Routine evaporator checks.
  • Locating a poor vessel.

Common mistakes

  • Readings taken at different times.
  • Forgetting the juice-heating surface of the first vessel.

Assumptions and limits

  • Steady operation during the readings.
  • In the formulas J is in t/h for s₁ and in kg/h for f_i, temperatures in °C and brix in %, as in Hugot; s₁ uses the juice boiling temperature T₁ + d₁ in effect 1.
  • Equal-evaporation (Rillieux) split: 1 kg of vapour evaporates 1 kg in the next effect. Flash of juice and condensate and heat losses are ignored. Each net drop must be positive, which also makes the vapour temperatures fall along the set.

References

  • Hugot
  • Handbook of Cane Sugar Engineering
  • 3rd ed. (Elsevier, 1986)
  • ch. 32
  • checking performance of a multiple effect
  • eqn 32.51 and example
  • pp. 600–602

Questions and answers

Why not measure each vessel's evaporation?

Condensates are hard to meter and one bad vessel shifts all the others; Hugot checks each vessel's drop against its surface instead.

What is s₁?

Part of the first vessel's surface heats the entering juice to its boiling point: about 0.1 m² per t/h per °C.

Hugot's example?

98 t/h at 960 kg juice/t, 14 → 56 brix: factors 0.00067–0.00074, about 70 % of normal, uniform, so scale is the cause.

Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.

Related calculators

Free engineering calculators: every page computes in SI and converts to your units. Results are for engineering estimation; verify critical designs against the referenced standards.

Rejoining the server...

Rejoin failed... trying again in seconds.

Failed to rejoin.
Please retry or reload the page.

The session has been paused by the server.

Failed to resume the session.
Please retry or reload the page.