Worked example
Example: Hugot example (quadruple). The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Number of effects | 4.0000 - |
| Total net temperature drop | 54.700 K |
| Evaporation of effect 1 | 31,673 kg/h |
| Evaporation of effect 2 | 20,469 kg/h |
| Evaporation of effect 3 | 16,954 kg/h |
| Evaporation of effect 4 | 10,904 kg/h |
| Evaporation of effect 5 | 0 kg/h |
| Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 1, kg/(m²·h·°C) | 5.5400 - |
| Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 2, kg/(m²·h·°C) | 4.3800 - |
| Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 3, kg/(m²·h·°C) | 3.0100 - |
| Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 4, kg/(m²·h·°C) | 1.4400 - |
| Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 5, kg/(m²·h·°C) | 1.0000 - |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Drop in effect 1 | 10.549 K |
| Drop in effect 2 | 10.455 K |
| Drop in effect 3 | 13.219 K |
| Drop in effect 4 | 20.477 K |
| Drop in effect 5 | 0 K |
| Heating surface of effect 1 | 541.96 m² |
| Heating surface of effect 2 | 446.98 m² |
| Heating surface of effect 3 | 426.09 m² |
| Heating surface of effect 4 | 369.80 m² |
| Heating surface of effect 5 | 0 m² |
| Total heating surface | 1,784.8 m² |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(t_i = \frac{q_i}{c_i}, \quad \frac{\Delta_{n-1}}{\Delta_n} = \sqrt{\frac{t_{n-1}}{2t_n}}, \quad \Delta_i = \sqrt{\frac{t_i\sum_{k>i}\Delta_k}{2\sum_{k>i}t_k/\Delta_k}}, \quad S_i = \frac{t_i}{\Delta_i^*}\)
\(\Delta_i^* = \Delta\frac{\Delta_i}{\sum_k \Delta_k} + k_i\Delta, \quad k = (+0.008, +0.006, +0.003, -0.017)\ (n = 4), \quad k = (+0.009, +0.007, +0.004, -0.003, -0.017)\ (n = 5), \quad k = 0\ (n = 3)\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(n\) | Number of effects | - |
| \(\Delta\) | Total net temperature drop | K |
| \(q_1\) | Evaporation of effect 1 | kg/s |
| \(q_2\) | Evaporation of effect 2 | kg/s |
| \(q_3\) | Evaporation of effect 3 | kg/s |
| \(q_4\) | Evaporation of effect 4 | kg/s |
| \(q_5\) | Evaporation of effect 5 | kg/s |
| \(c_1\) | Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 1, kg/(m²·h·°C) | - |
| \(c_2\) | Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 2, kg/(m²·h·°C) | - |
| \(c_3\) | Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 3, kg/(m²·h·°C) | - |
| \(c_4\) | Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 4, kg/(m²·h·°C) | - |
| \(c_5\) | Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 5, kg/(m²·h·°C) | - |
| \(\Delta_1\) | Drop in effect 1 | K |
| \(\Delta_2\) | Drop in effect 2 | K |
| \(\Delta_3\) | Drop in effect 3 | K |
| \(\Delta_4\) | Drop in effect 4 | K |
| \(\Delta_5\) | Drop in effect 5 | K |
| \(S_1\) | Heating surface of effect 1 | m² |
| \(S_2\) | Heating surface of effect 2 | m² |
| \(S_3\) | Heating surface of effect 3 | m² |
| \(S_4\) | Heating surface of effect 4 | m² |
| \(S_5\) | Heating surface of effect 5 | m² |
| \(S\) | Total heating surface | m² |
| \(t_i\) | Evaporation capacity q_i/c_i of effect i | m²·°C |
| \(\Delta_i^*\) | Drop of effect i after scaling to Δ and the correction | K |
| \(k_i\) | Correction to the drop of effect i, share of the total drop | - |
Method and standards
Hugot's recurrence quotients for minimum total surface.
Where it is used
- Optimising a new evaporator.
- Judging an unbalanced set.
Common mistakes
- Using apparent instead of net drops.
- Entering coefficients in W/(m²·K).
Assumptions and limits
- Coefficients from Dessin's formula at the first-guess temperatures; they are entered and shown in kg/(m²·h·°C) in every unit system.
- The recurrence drops are scaled so that they add up to the total drop, then the corrections k_i (shares of the total drop) are added. If a corrected drop comes out zero or negative the calculation stops with a message. The drops shown as outputs are the corrected ones.
References
- Hugot
- Handbook of Cane Sugar Engineering
- 3rd ed. (Elsevier, 1986)
- ch. 32
- minimum total heating surface
- eqns 32.35–32.47 and example
- pp. 581–595
Questions and answers
What are t = q/c?
Hugot's evaporation capacities: the product of surface and drop each effect needs; the method shares the total drop to minimise ΣS.
Does it save much?
Rarely more than a few percent: Hugot finds the minimum flat, so standard pressure scales are close to optimal.
Why the corrections?
Boiling-point elevation grows faster than the drops; Hugot adds +0.8, +0.6, +0.3 and −1.7 % of the total drop for a quadruple.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.