Worked example
Example: Hugot example: 98 TCH quadruple. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Clear juice to the evaporator | 94.080 t/h |
| Clear juice brix | 14.000 % |
| Syrup brix | 56.000 % |
| Juice temperature entering effect 1 | 96.000 °C |
| Number of effects | 4.0000 - |
| Heating steam temperature (effect 1) | 115.00 °C |
| Vapour temperature leaving effect 1 | 105.00 °C |
| Vapour temperature leaving effect 2 | 94.000 °C |
| Vapour temperature leaving effect 3 | 81.000 °C |
| Vapour temperature leaving effect 4 | 54.000 °C |
| Vapour temperature leaving effect 5 | 54.000 °C |
| Boiling-point rise in effect 1 (brix and head) | 1.0000 K |
| Boiling-point rise in effect 2 (brix and head) | 1.5000 K |
| Boiling-point rise in effect 3 (brix and head) | 2.0000 K |
| Boiling-point rise in effect 4 (brix and head) | 5.7000 K |
| Boiling-point rise in effect 5 (brix and head) | 5.7000 K |
| Vapour bled from effect 1 | 10,000 kg/h |
| Vapour bled from effect 2 | 5,000.0 kg/h |
| Vapour bled from effect 3 | 0 kg/h |
| Vapour bled from effect 4 | 0 kg/h |
| Heating surface of effect 1 | 1,000.0 m² |
| Heating surface of effect 2 | 700.00 m² |
| Heating surface of effect 3 | 600.00 m² |
| Heating surface of effect 4 | 550.00 m² |
| Heating surface of effect 5 | 500.00 m² |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Total evaporation | 70,560 kg/h |
| Surface of effect 1 used to heat the juice 0.1 Q(t₁ − t₀) | 94.080 m² |
| Evaporation of effect 1 | 27,640 kg/h |
| Evaporation of effect 2 | 17,640 kg/h |
| Evaporation of effect 3 | 12,640 kg/h |
| Evaporation of effect 4 | 12,640 kg/h |
| Evaporation of effect 5 | 0 kg/h |
| Dessin factor achieved by effect 1 | 6.6886e-04 |
| Dessin factor achieved by effect 2 | 6.7908e-04 |
| Dessin factor achieved by effect 3 | 7.0108e-04 |
| Dessin factor achieved by effect 4 | 7.4295e-04 |
| Dessin factor achieved by effect 5 | 0 |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(E = J\left(1 - \frac{B_0}{B_s}\right), \quad x = \frac{E - \sum_{i<n} i P_i}{n}, \quad q_i = x + \sum_{k=i}^{n-1} P_k\)
\(s_1 = 0.1\,J\,(T_1 + d_1 - t_0), \quad \Delta_i = T_{i-1} - T_i - d_i, \quad f_i = \frac{q_i}{(100 - \bar b_i)(T_{i-1} - 54)(S_i - s_1\,[i = 1])\,\Delta_i}\)
\(b_i = \frac{100\,B_0 J}{J - \sum_{k\le i} q_k}, \quad \bar b_i = \frac{b_{i-1} + b_i}{2}\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(J\) | Clear juice to the evaporator | kg/s |
| \(B_0\) | Clear juice brix | - |
| \(B_s\) | Syrup brix | - |
| \(t_0\) | Juice temperature entering effect 1 | K |
| \(n\) | Number of effects | - |
| \(T_0\) | Heating steam temperature (effect 1) | K |
| \(T_1\) | Vapour temperature leaving effect 1 | K |
| \(T_2\) | Vapour temperature leaving effect 2 | K |
| \(T_3\) | Vapour temperature leaving effect 3 | K |
| \(T_4\) | Vapour temperature leaving effect 4 | K |
| \(T_5\) | Vapour temperature leaving effect 5 | K |
| \(d_1\) | Boiling-point rise in effect 1 (brix and head) | K |
| \(d_2\) | Boiling-point rise in effect 2 (brix and head) | K |
| \(d_3\) | Boiling-point rise in effect 3 (brix and head) | K |
| \(d_4\) | Boiling-point rise in effect 4 (brix and head) | K |
| \(d_5\) | Boiling-point rise in effect 5 (brix and head) | K |
| \(P_1\) | Vapour bled from effect 1 | kg/s |
| \(P_2\) | Vapour bled from effect 2 | kg/s |
| \(P_3\) | Vapour bled from effect 3 | kg/s |
| \(P_4\) | Vapour bled from effect 4 | kg/s |
| \(S_1\) | Heating surface of effect 1 | m² |
| \(S_2\) | Heating surface of effect 2 | m² |
| \(S_3\) | Heating surface of effect 3 | m² |
| \(S_4\) | Heating surface of effect 4 | m² |
| \(S_5\) | Heating surface of effect 5 | m² |
| \(E\) | Total evaporation | kg/s |
| \(s_1\) | Surface of effect 1 used to heat the juice 0.1 Q(t₁ − t₀) | m² |
| \(q_1\) | Evaporation of effect 1 | kg/s |
| \(q_2\) | Evaporation of effect 2 | kg/s |
| \(q_3\) | Evaporation of effect 3 | kg/s |
| \(q_4\) | Evaporation of effect 4 | kg/s |
| \(q_5\) | Evaporation of effect 5 | kg/s |
| \(f_1\) | Dessin factor achieved by effect 1 | - |
| \(f_2\) | Dessin factor achieved by effect 2 | - |
| \(f_3\) | Dessin factor achieved by effect 3 | - |
| \(f_4\) | Dessin factor achieved by effect 4 | - |
| \(f_5\) | Dessin factor achieved by effect 5 | - |
| \(x\) | Evaporation each effect would give with no bleeding | kg/s |
| \(\Delta_i\) | Net temperature drop of effect i | K |
| \(b_i, \bar b_i\) | Brix leaving effect i and mean brix in it (%) | - |
Method and standards
Hugot's performance check with Dessin's formula.
Where it is used
- Routine evaporator checks.
- Locating a poor vessel.
Common mistakes
- Readings taken at different times.
- Forgetting the juice-heating surface of the first vessel.
Assumptions and limits
- Steady operation during the readings.
- In the formulas J is in t/h for s₁ and in kg/h for f_i, temperatures in °C and brix in %, as in Hugot; s₁ uses the juice boiling temperature T₁ + d₁ in effect 1.
- Equal-evaporation (Rillieux) split: 1 kg of vapour evaporates 1 kg in the next effect. Flash of juice and condensate and heat losses are ignored. Each net drop must be positive, which also makes the vapour temperatures fall along the set.
References
- Hugot
- Handbook of Cane Sugar Engineering
- 3rd ed. (Elsevier, 1986)
- ch. 32
- checking performance of a multiple effect
- eqn 32.51 and example
- pp. 600–602
Questions and answers
Why not measure each vessel's evaporation?
Condensates are hard to meter and one bad vessel shifts all the others; Hugot checks each vessel's drop against its surface instead.
What is s₁?
Part of the first vessel's surface heats the entering juice to its boiling point: about 0.1 m² per t/h per °C.
Hugot's example?
98 t/h at 960 kg juice/t, 14 → 56 brix: factors 0.00067–0.00074, about 70 % of normal, uniform, so scale is the cause.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.