FireCADCalc

Evaporator Temperature Drops for Minimum Surface

Temperature drops that give the minimum total heating surface of a 3- to 5-effect evaporator from each effect's evaporation and coefficient (Hugot eqns 32.44–32.47).

Sugar mill and cogeneration

Inputs

Examples: Hugot example (quadruple)Triple

Results

Drops include Hugot's corrections for quadruple and quintuple effects (none given for triples). Surfaces keep the entered coefficients; recompute them for the new temperatures if they move much.

Drop in effect 110.637K
Drop in effect 212.783K
Drop in effect 321.580K
Drop in effect 40K
Drop in effect 50K
Heating surface of effect 1470.06m²
Heating surface of effect 2411.73m²
Heating surface of effect 3347.54m²
Heating surface of effect 40m²
Heating surface of effect 50m²
Total heating surface1,229.3m²

Download PDF CSV Link to this result Compare another case

Log in to save calculations to your dashboard.

Worked example

Example: Hugot example (quadruple). The inputs, in the units selected above:

InputValue
Number of effects4.0000 -
Total net temperature drop54.700 K
Evaporation of effect 131,673 kg/h
Evaporation of effect 220,469 kg/h
Evaporation of effect 316,954 kg/h
Evaporation of effect 410,904 kg/h
Evaporation of effect 50 kg/h
Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 1, kg/(m²·h·°C)5.5400 -
Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 2, kg/(m²·h·°C)4.3800 -
Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 3, kg/(m²·h·°C)3.0100 -
Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 4, kg/(m²·h·°C)1.4400 -
Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 5, kg/(m²·h·°C)1.0000 -

Applying the formula below gives:

ResultValue
Drop in effect 110.549 K
Drop in effect 210.455 K
Drop in effect 313.219 K
Drop in effect 420.477 K
Drop in effect 50 K
Heating surface of effect 1541.96 m²
Heating surface of effect 2446.98 m²
Heating surface of effect 3426.09 m²
Heating surface of effect 4369.80 m²
Heating surface of effect 50 m²
Total heating surface1,784.8 m²

Open this example in the calculator and change any input.

Formula

\(t_i = \frac{q_i}{c_i}, \quad \frac{\Delta_{n-1}}{\Delta_n} = \sqrt{\frac{t_{n-1}}{2t_n}}, \quad \Delta_i = \sqrt{\frac{t_i\sum_{k>i}\Delta_k}{2\sum_{k>i}t_k/\Delta_k}}, \quad S_i = \frac{t_i}{\Delta_i^*}\)

\(\Delta_i^* = \Delta\frac{\Delta_i}{\sum_k \Delta_k} + k_i\Delta, \quad k = (+0.008, +0.006, +0.003, -0.017)\ (n = 4), \quad k = (+0.009, +0.007, +0.004, -0.003, -0.017)\ (n = 5), \quad k = 0\ (n = 3)\)

Variables

Symbol Meaning SI unit
\(n\) Number of effects -
\(\Delta\) Total net temperature drop K
\(q_1\) Evaporation of effect 1 kg/s
\(q_2\) Evaporation of effect 2 kg/s
\(q_3\) Evaporation of effect 3 kg/s
\(q_4\) Evaporation of effect 4 kg/s
\(q_5\) Evaporation of effect 5 kg/s
\(c_1\) Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 1, kg/(m²·h·°C) -
\(c_2\) Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 2, kg/(m²·h·°C) -
\(c_3\) Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 3, kg/(m²·h·°C) -
\(c_4\) Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 4, kg/(m²·h·°C) -
\(c_5\) Specific evaporation coefficient of effect 5, kg/(m²·h·°C) -
\(\Delta_1\) Drop in effect 1 K
\(\Delta_2\) Drop in effect 2 K
\(\Delta_3\) Drop in effect 3 K
\(\Delta_4\) Drop in effect 4 K
\(\Delta_5\) Drop in effect 5 K
\(S_1\) Heating surface of effect 1 m²
\(S_2\) Heating surface of effect 2 m²
\(S_3\) Heating surface of effect 3 m²
\(S_4\) Heating surface of effect 4 m²
\(S_5\) Heating surface of effect 5 m²
\(S\) Total heating surface m²
\(t_i\) Evaporation capacity q_i/c_i of effect i m²·°C
\(\Delta_i^*\) Drop of effect i after scaling to Δ and the correction K
\(k_i\) Correction to the drop of effect i, share of the total drop -

Method and standards

Hugot's recurrence quotients for minimum total surface.

Where it is used

  • Optimising a new evaporator.
  • Judging an unbalanced set.

Common mistakes

  • Using apparent instead of net drops.
  • Entering coefficients in W/(m²·K).

Assumptions and limits

  • Coefficients from Dessin's formula at the first-guess temperatures; they are entered and shown in kg/(m²·h·°C) in every unit system.
  • The recurrence drops are scaled so that they add up to the total drop, then the corrections k_i (shares of the total drop) are added. If a corrected drop comes out zero or negative the calculation stops with a message. The drops shown as outputs are the corrected ones.

References

  • Hugot
  • Handbook of Cane Sugar Engineering
  • 3rd ed. (Elsevier, 1986)
  • ch. 32
  • minimum total heating surface
  • eqns 32.35–32.47 and example
  • pp. 581–595

Questions and answers

What are t = q/c?

Hugot's evaporation capacities: the product of surface and drop each effect needs; the method shares the total drop to minimise ΣS.

Does it save much?

Rarely more than a few percent: Hugot finds the minimum flat, so standard pressure scales are close to optimal.

Why the corrections?

Boiling-point elevation grows faster than the drops; Hugot adds +0.8, +0.6, +0.3 and −1.7 % of the total drop for a quadruple.

Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.

Related calculators

Free engineering calculators: every page computes in SI and converts to your units. Results are for engineering estimation; verify critical designs against the referenced standards.

Rejoining the server...

Rejoin failed... trying again in seconds.

Failed to rejoin.
Please retry or reload the page.

The session has been paused by the server.

Failed to resume the session.
Please retry or reload the page.