Worked example
Example: ID fan 150 kW at 75 % flow, all friction, damper 85 %. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Shaft power at the design duty (100 % flow) | 150.00 kW |
| Operating flow as a share of design | 75.000 % |
| Static share of the design pressure or head | 0 % |
| Shaft power with the damper or valve at this flow, as a share of P_d | 85.000 % |
| Drive (VFD) efficiency | 97.000 % |
| Motor efficiency | 95.000 % |
| Hours per year at this flow | 8,000.0 h |
| Electricity price per kWh (your currency) | 8.0000 - |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Electrical power saved | 65.539 kW |
| Energy saved per year | 524.31 MWh |
| Cost saved per year (your currency) | 4,194,466 |
| Electrical input with damper or valve | 134.21 kW |
| Electrical input with VFD | 68.672 kW |
| Shaft power with VFD | 63.281 kW |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(P_v = P_d\,f\left(s + (1-s)f^2\right) \qquad P_{e,v} = \frac{P_v}{\eta_m\,\eta_v} \qquad P_{e,t} = \frac{r_t\,P_d}{\eta_m}\)
\(\Delta P = P_{e,t} - P_{e,v} \qquad \Delta E = \Delta P\,t_{op} \qquad \Delta C = \Delta E\,[\text{kWh}]\cdot c_e\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(P_d\) | shaft power at the design duty | W |
| \(f\) | operating flow as a share of design | – |
| \(s\) | static share of the design pressure or head | – |
| \(r_t\) | throttled shaft power as a share of \(P_d\) | – |
| \(\eta_v\) | drive efficiency | – |
| \(\eta_m\) | motor efficiency | – |
| \(t_{op}\) | hours per year at this flow | s |
| \(c_e\) | electricity price per kWh | – |
| \(\Delta P\) | electrical power saved | W |
| \(\Delta E\) | energy saved per year | J |
| \(\Delta C\) | cost saved per year | – |
| \(P_{e,t}\) | electrical input with damper or valve | W |
| \(P_{e,v}\) | electrical input with VFD | W |
| \(P_v\) | shaft power with VFD | W |
Method and standards
With speed control the machine follows the system curve \(p = p_d(s + (1-s)f^2)\); at constant machine efficiency the shaft power is proportional to flow times pressure (the affinity laws of AMCA 99 and ANSI/HI 1.3 when \(s = 0\)). The throttled power comes from the machine's own curve at full speed.
Where it is used
- Justifying variable speed drives on pumps and fans.
- Energy audits of throttled systems.
- Comparing damper and speed control.
Common mistakes
- Using the cube law where static head is large.
- Ignoring drive losses.
- Assuming full-load hours when the load varies.
Assumptions and limits
- Machine efficiency taken as constant at reduced speed: exact for \(s = 0\), optimistic when the static share is large.
- Motor efficiency taken as equal in both cases; at low load it falls, which slightly favours the VFD.
- One operating point; for a load profile add the savings of each point weighted by its hours.
References
- Fan and pump affinity laws (AMCA 99, ANSI/HI 1.3)
Questions and answers
How much does a VFD save on a fan?
On an all-friction system the shaft power falls with the cube of flow. An ID fan of 150 kW running at 75 % flow needs 63 kW with a VFD against about 128 kW with its damper, saving 66 kW of electricity.
Why is the saving smaller on a feed pump?
A boiler feed pump must always reach drum pressure, so most of its head is static and does not fall with speed. At 80 % flow with 60 % static head the saving in the example is 45 kW of 194 kW.
Where do I get the throttled power?
From the fan or pump curve at the reduced flow and full speed (for inlet vanes, from the maker's vane curves). It is an input because it depends on the machine.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 10 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.