Worked example
Example: Ganapathy: 230 gpm, 970 ft, 6000 h. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Flow | 52.239 m³/h |
| Head | 295.66 m |
| Liquid density | 999.00 kg/m³ |
| Pump efficiency | 70.000 % |
| Motor efficiency | 90.000 % |
| Turbine mechanical efficiency | 95.000 % |
| Boiler efficiency (same GCV or NCV basis as the fuel price) | 85.000 % |
| Electricity price per kWh | 0.050000 - |
| Fuel price per GJ (same CV basis as the boiler efficiency) | 2.8435 - |
| Operating hours per year | 6,000.0 h |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Pump shaft power | 60.043 kW |
| Annual cost, motor drive | 20,014 |
| Annual cost, steam turbine drive | 4,566.9 |
| Annual saving with the turbine | 15,448 |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(P = \frac{\rho g Q H}{\eta_p}, \quad C_m = \frac{P}{\eta_m}\,t\,c_e, \quad C_t = \frac{P}{\eta_t\,\eta_b}\,t\,c_f\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(Q\) | Flow | m³/s |
| \(H\) | Head | m |
| \(\rho\) | Liquid density | kg/m³ |
| \(\eta_p\) | Pump efficiency | - |
| \(\eta_m\) | Motor efficiency | - |
| \(\eta_t\) | Turbine mechanical efficiency | - |
| \(\eta_b\) | Boiler efficiency (same GCV or NCV basis as the fuel price) | - |
| \(c_e\) | Electricity price per kWh | - |
| \(c_f\) | Fuel price per GJ (same CV basis as the boiler efficiency) | - |
| \(t\) | Operating hours per year | s |
| \(P\) | Pump shaft power | W |
| \(C_m\) | Annual cost, motor drive | - |
| \(C_t\) | Annual cost, steam turbine drive | - |
| \(C_m - C_t\) | Annual saving with the turbine | - |
Method and standards
Ganapathy's comparison (back-pressure exhaust fully used).
Where it is used
- Feed pump and fan drive selection in cogeneration plants.
Common mistakes
- Ignoring that vented exhaust steam costs its full enthalpy.
- Mixing currency units.
Assumptions and limits
- Exhaust steam fully used for process.
- Boiler efficiency and fuel price on one calorific-value basis (both GCV or both NCV).
- Turbine steam rate, back-pressure, capital and maintenance costs are not modelled.
References
- Ganapathy
- Steam Plant Calculations Manual
- 2nd ed. (Marcel Dekker, 1993)
- Q5.08 (electric and steam turbine drives for pumps)
Questions and answers
Why is the turbine so cheap to run?
With the exhaust used for process, only the heat turned into shaft work is extra fuel: about 1/(η_t η_b) of the shaft energy.
What does Ganapathy's example give?
230 gpm at 970 ft: about $20,100 a year by motor against $4,600 by turbine.
What about capital cost?
Turbines, steam piping and governors cost more; compare payback.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.