Worked example
Example: 15 rollers. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Number of rollers in the tandem | 15.000 - |
| Preparation index | 88.000 % |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Gain from knives 3/(N − 6) | 0.33333 % |
| Gain from a Searby-type shredder 7.5/(N − 8) | 1.0714 % |
| Gain from a Maxwell-type shredder 2.5/(N − 8) | 0.35714 % |
| Gain, high-power over normal shredder 10.7/(N − 8) | 1.5286 % |
| First-mill extraction ≈ 1.02 I.P. | 89.760 % |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(\varepsilon_k = \frac{3}{N-6}\,\%, \quad \varepsilon_S = \frac{7.5}{N-8}\,\%, \quad \varepsilon_M = \frac{2.5}{N-8}\,\%, \quad \varepsilon_H = \frac{10.7}{N-8}\,\%, \quad e_1 \approx \min(1,\ 1.02\,I.P.)\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(N\) | Number of rollers in the tandem | - |
| \(I.P.\) | Preparation index | - |
| \(\varepsilon_k\) | Gain from knives 3/(N − 6) | - |
| \(\varepsilon_S\) | Gain from a Searby-type shredder 7.5/(N − 8) | - |
| \(\varepsilon_M\) | Gain from a Maxwell-type shredder 2.5/(N − 8) | - |
| \(\varepsilon_H\) | Gain, high-power over normal shredder 10.7/(N − 8) | - |
| \(e_1\) | First-mill extraction ≈ 1.02 I.P. | - |
Method and standards
Hugot's empirical relations from mill results.
Where it is used
- Judging the value of a shredder or knife upgrade.
- Setting first-mill extraction targets.
Common mistakes
- Reading the gains as fractions instead of percentage points.
- Applying them to diffusers.
Assumptions and limits
- Empirical relations for conventional milling tandems, from Hugot's mill results; no validity range is given, and short tandems give large gains (7.5 points for a Searby shredder at 9 rollers), so treat the extremes as indicative.
- e₁ is the first-mill pol extraction, capped at 100 % above I.P. 0.98.
References
- Hugot
- Handbook of Cane Sugar Engineering
- 3rd ed. (Elsevier, 1986)
- ch. 20
- Table 20.1
- p. 321; ch. 6
- eqn 6.2 (Moor) and the Bingera relation e = 1.02 I.P.
- pp. 61–69
Questions and answers
Why does the gain depend on the number of rollers?
A long tandem makes up for poor preparation with more pressings, so a shredder gains less there.
What is the Searby shredder?
A hammer-type shredder; Maxwell shredders are lighter, rotating-knife types.
Is e₁ = 1.02 I.P. general?
It is the Bingera relation for the first mill; use it as an estimate only.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.