FireCADCalc

Extraction Gain from Cane Preparation (Hugot)

Extraction gained by knives and shredders for the number of rollers in the tandem (Hugot Table 20.1, eqn 6.2), and first-mill extraction from preparation index.

Sugar mill and cogeneration

Inputs

Examples: 15 rollers18 rollers

Results

Gains are percentage points of extraction; they shrink as the tandem gets longer because later mills recover what poor preparation leaves.

Gain from knives 3/(N − 6)0.33333%
Gain from a Searby-type shredder 7.5/(N − 8)1.0714%
Gain from a Maxwell-type shredder 2.5/(N − 8)0.35714%
Gain, high-power over normal shredder 10.7/(N − 8)1.5286%
First-mill extraction ≈ 1.02 I.P.89.760%

Download PDF CSV Link to this result Compare another case

Log in to save calculations to your dashboard.

Worked example

Example: 15 rollers. The inputs, in the units selected above:

InputValue
Number of rollers in the tandem15.000 -
Preparation index88.000 %

Applying the formula below gives:

ResultValue
Gain from knives 3/(N − 6)0.33333 %
Gain from a Searby-type shredder 7.5/(N − 8)1.0714 %
Gain from a Maxwell-type shredder 2.5/(N − 8)0.35714 %
Gain, high-power over normal shredder 10.7/(N − 8)1.5286 %
First-mill extraction ≈ 1.02 I.P.89.760 %

Open this example in the calculator and change any input.

Formula

\(\varepsilon_k = \frac{3}{N-6}\,\%, \quad \varepsilon_S = \frac{7.5}{N-8}\,\%, \quad \varepsilon_M = \frac{2.5}{N-8}\,\%, \quad \varepsilon_H = \frac{10.7}{N-8}\,\%, \quad e_1 \approx \min(1,\ 1.02\,I.P.)\)

Variables

Symbol Meaning SI unit
\(N\) Number of rollers in the tandem -
\(I.P.\) Preparation index -
\(\varepsilon_k\) Gain from knives 3/(N − 6) -
\(\varepsilon_S\) Gain from a Searby-type shredder 7.5/(N − 8) -
\(\varepsilon_M\) Gain from a Maxwell-type shredder 2.5/(N − 8) -
\(\varepsilon_H\) Gain, high-power over normal shredder 10.7/(N − 8) -
\(e_1\) First-mill extraction ≈ 1.02 I.P. -

Method and standards

Hugot's empirical relations from mill results.

Where it is used

  • Judging the value of a shredder or knife upgrade.
  • Setting first-mill extraction targets.

Common mistakes

  • Reading the gains as fractions instead of percentage points.
  • Applying them to diffusers.

Assumptions and limits

  • Empirical relations for conventional milling tandems, from Hugot's mill results; no validity range is given, and short tandems give large gains (7.5 points for a Searby shredder at 9 rollers), so treat the extremes as indicative.
  • e₁ is the first-mill pol extraction, capped at 100 % above I.P. 0.98.

References

  • Hugot
  • Handbook of Cane Sugar Engineering
  • 3rd ed. (Elsevier, 1986)
  • ch. 20
  • Table 20.1
  • p. 321; ch. 6
  • eqn 6.2 (Moor) and the Bingera relation e = 1.02 I.P.
  • pp. 61–69

Questions and answers

Why does the gain depend on the number of rollers?

A long tandem makes up for poor preparation with more pressings, so a shredder gains less there.

What is the Searby shredder?

A hammer-type shredder; Maxwell shredders are lighter, rotating-knife types.

Is e₁ = 1.02 I.P. general?

It is the Bingera relation for the first mill; use it as an estimate only.

Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.

Related calculators

Free engineering calculators: every page computes in SI and converts to your units. Results are for engineering estimation; verify critical designs against the referenced standards.

Rejoining the server...

Rejoin failed... trying again in seconds.

Failed to rejoin.
Please retry or reload the page.

The session has been paused by the server.

Failed to resume the session.
Please retry or reload the page.