Worked example
Example: Duda Example 15.1: 65 / 55 / 95 % passing, 15 t/h fines. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Separator feed passing the test sieve | 65.000 % |
| Tailings (rejects) passing the sieve | 55.000 % |
| Fines (product) passing the sieve | 95.000 % |
| Fines (product) rate | 15.000 t/h |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Circulating load (tailings / fines) | 300.00 % |
| Tailings rate | 45.000 t/h |
| Separator feed rate | 60.000 t/h |
| Recovery of fines in the feed to the product | 36.538 % |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(L = \frac{C - A}{A - B}, \quad G = L D, \quad F = (L + 1)D, \quad E = \frac{C(A - B)}{A(C - B)}\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(A\) | Separator feed passing the test sieve | - |
| \(B\) | Tailings (rejects) passing the sieve | - |
| \(C\) | Fines (product) passing the sieve | - |
| \(D\) | Fines (product) rate | kg/s |
| \(L\) | Circulating load (tailings / fines) | - |
| \(G\) | Tailings rate | kg/s |
| \(F\) | Separator feed rate | kg/s |
| \(E\) | Recovery of fines in the feed to the product | - |
Method and standards
Two-product balance on the separator.
Where it is used
- Closed-circuit cement and raw mill audits.
- Separator tuning.
Common mistakes
- Mixing passing and residue data.
- Sampling at different times.
Assumptions and limits
- Steady state.
References
- Duda
- Cement Data Book
- Vol. 1
- 3rd ed. (Bauverlag / Macdonald and Evans, 1985)
- sec. 15.8 (air separator formulas) and Examples 15.1-15.2
Questions and answers
Why is the circulating load so high in cement mills?
Returning coarse rejects lets the mill grind for a short time per pass, avoiding overgrinding; 150–300 % is common.
Can I use Blaine instead of sieve passing?
Only sieve-type measures add linearly; Blaine surface does not mix linearly and gives errors.
What do the defaults represent?
Duda's Example 15.1: 65, 55 and 95 % passing 200 mesh in feed, tailings and fines, 15 t/h fines (300 %, 45 t/h tailings, 60 t/h feed).
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 17 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.