Worked example
Example: Ganapathy Q8.17 water tube: 50,000 lb/h at 950 °F, 520 °F measured (book 471 °F, 0.63 MM Btu/h, $15,120). The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Boiler type | Water tube (U ∝ W_g^0.6) |
| Reference (clean) gas flow | 34,019 kg/h |
| Reference gas inlet temperature | 537.78 °C |
| Reference gas exit temperature | 260.00 °C |
| Reference steam pressure (absolute) | 20.684 bar |
| Present gas flow | 22,680 kg/h |
| Present gas inlet temperature | 510.00 °C |
| Present steam pressure (absolute) | 20.684 bar |
| Measured present exit gas temperature | 271.11 °C |
| Gas specific heat | 1.0886 kJ/(kg·K) |
| Operating hours per year | 8,000.0 h |
| Cost of heat (currency per GJ) | 2.8435 - |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Present saturation temperature | 214.09 °C |
| Predicted clean exit gas temperature | 243.85 °C |
| Exit temperature rise due to fouling | 27.264 K |
| Heat lost to fouling | 186.97 kW |
| Annual cost of the lost heat (currency) | 15,311 |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(\ln\frac{T_{g1} - T_s}{T_{g2} - T_s} = \frac{UA}{W_gc_p} \propto W_g^{-0.2}\ \text{(fire tube)},\ W_g^{-0.4}\ \text{(water tube)}, \quad Q_{loss} = W_gc_p(T_{g2,meas} - T_{g2,pred})\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(\text{type}\) | Boiler type | - |
| \(W_{g,1}\) | Reference (clean) gas flow | kg/s |
| \(T_{g1,1}\) | Reference gas inlet temperature | K |
| \(T_{g2,1}\) | Reference gas exit temperature | K |
| \(p_1\) | Reference steam pressure (absolute) | Pa |
| \(W_{g,2}\) | Present gas flow | kg/s |
| \(T_{g1,2}\) | Present gas inlet temperature | K |
| \(p_2\) | Present steam pressure (absolute) | Pa |
| \(T_{g2,meas}\) | Measured present exit gas temperature | K |
| \(c_p\) | Gas specific heat | J/(kg·K) |
| \(t_a\) | Operating hours per year | s |
| \(c_E\) | Cost of heat (currency per GJ) | - |
| \(T_s\) | Present saturation temperature | K |
| \(T_{g2,pred}\) | Predicted clean exit gas temperature | K |
| \(\Delta T\) | Exit temperature rise due to fouling | K |
| \(Q_{loss}\) | Heat lost to fouling | W |
| \(C\) | Annual cost of the lost heat (currency) | - |
Method and standards
Ganapathy's evaporator scaling: the clean exit temperature at the present flow, inlet temperature and pressure follows from the reference test with UA/(W_g c_p) scaled as W_g−0.2 (fire tube) or W_g−0.4 (water tube). The heat lost is the gas heat between the measured and predicted exit temperatures, costed per GJ for the operating hours.
Where it is used
- Waste heat and fire-tube boiler monitoring.
- Deciding when to clean.
Common mistakes
- Using a reference already fouled.
- Ignoring a change in steam pressure.
Assumptions and limits
- Evaporator only; gas-side-controlled U.
- The 5 K margin for flagging fouling is a FireCAD rule of thumb for measurement scatter, not a sourced figure.
- A measured exit below the clean prediction gives a negative heat loss and dT (no fouling); the cost is then zero.
References
- Ganapathy
- Industrial Boilers and Heat Recovery Steam Generators (Marcel Dekker, 2003)
- Q8.15a and Q8.17 (evaporator performance and fouling inferred from operating data); IAPWS-IF97 saturation
Questions and answers
Why can exit gas temperature reveal fouling?
For an evaporator, ln[(T_in − T_s)/(T_out − T_s)] = UA/(W_g c_p); with U scaling as a power of gas flow, the clean exit temperature at any load follows from one clean test.
What does Ganapathy's example give?
Clean: 75,000 lb/h, 1,000 → 500 °F at 300 psia. At 50,000 lb/h and 950 °F, clean exit should be 471 °F; 520 °F measured means about 0.63 MM Btu/h lost, $15,120 a year at $3/MM Btu.
Why different exponents?
In fire tubes the gas film inside the tubes governs (U ∝ W_g0.8); in water tubes the cross-flow gas film (U ∝ W_g0.6).
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.