Worked example
Example: Ganapathy Q4.35: 165,000 lb/h at 880 °F, 150 psig (expect 388 °F, 21.7 MM Btu/h, ~25,300 lb/h, ~301 °F). The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Design gas flow | 17.640 kg/s |
| Design gas inlet temperature | 526.67 °C |
| Design gas temperature leaving the evaporator | 208.89 °C |
| Design drum pressure (absolute) | 14.803 bar |
| Design economiser duty | 1,125.4 kW |
| Design economiser LMTD | 27.778 K |
| New gas flow | 20.790 kg/s |
| New gas inlet temperature | 471.11 °C |
| New drum pressure (absolute) | 11.356 bar |
| Feedwater temperature | 110.00 °C |
| Blowdown fraction of steam | 5.0000 % |
| Gas specific heat, evaporator | 1.1304 kJ/(kg·K) |
| Gas specific heat, economiser | 1.0593 kJ/(kg·K) |
| Heat retention factor (1 − casing loss) | 99.000 % |
| Exponent of gas flow in the economiser UA | 0.65000 - |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Saturation temperature | 185.49 °C |
| Gas leaving the evaporator | 197.56 °C |
| Evaporator duty | 6,364.5 kW |
| Steam generated | 11,456 kg/h |
| Water leaving the economiser | 184.26 °C |
| Economiser duty | 1,069.1 kW |
| Exit (stack) gas temperature | 148.52 °C |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(\ln\frac{T_{g1} - T_s}{T_{g2} - T_s} = \ln\frac{T_{g1,d} - T_{s,d}}{T_{g2,d} - T_{s,d}}\left(\frac{W_g}{W_{g,d}}\right)^{-0.4}, \quad Q_{ev} = W_gc_ph_l(T_{g1} - T_{g2})\)
\(\dot m_s = \frac{Q_{ev}}{(h_g - h_{w2}) + b(h_f - h_{w2})}, \quad Q_{ec} = \dot m_s(1 + b)(h_{w2} - h_{fw}) = UA\,\Delta T_{lm}, \quad UA = \frac{Q_{e,d}}{\Delta T_{lm,d}}\left(\frac{W_g}{W_{g,d}}\right)^m\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(W_{g,d}\) | Design gas flow | kg/s |
| \(T_{g1,d}\) | Design gas inlet temperature | K |
| \(T_{g2,d}\) | Design gas temperature leaving the evaporator | K |
| \(p_d\) | Design drum pressure (absolute) | Pa |
| \(Q_{e,d}\) | Design economiser duty | W |
| \(\Delta T_{lm,d}\) | Design economiser LMTD | K |
| \(W_g\) | New gas flow | kg/s |
| \(T_{g1}\) | New gas inlet temperature | K |
| \(p\) | New drum pressure (absolute) | Pa |
| \(T_{fw}\) | Feedwater temperature | K |
| \(b\) | Blowdown fraction of steam | - |
| \(c_{p,ev}\) | Gas specific heat, evaporator | J/(kg·K) |
| \(c_{p,ec}\) | Gas specific heat, economiser | J/(kg·K) |
| \(h_l\) | Heat retention factor (1 − casing loss) | - |
| \(m\) | Exponent of gas flow in the economiser UA | - |
| \(T_s\) | Saturation temperature | K |
| \(T_{g2}\) | Gas leaving the evaporator | K |
| \(Q_{ev}\) | Evaporator duty | W |
| \(\dot m_s\) | Steam generated | kg/s |
| \(T_{w2}\) | Water leaving the economiser | K |
| \(Q_{ec}\) | Economiser duty | W |
| \(T_{g3}\) | Exit (stack) gas temperature | K |
Method and standards
Ganapathy's NTU-type simulation, solved for the economiser outlet temperature by bisection between the feedwater temperature + 0.01 K and the saturation temperature, after checking that the heat balance changes sign in that range. The new gas inlet must be at least 1 K above saturation. If the economiser could heat the water past saturation, the water is taken to leave at saturation, as in Ganapathy's Q4.41, and a warning is shown.
Where it is used
- Gas turbine HRSG performance at ambient and load changes.
- Checking guarantees and economiser steaming.
Common mistakes
- Using design steam per kg of gas at off-design.
- Ignoring economiser steaming at low pressure.
Assumptions and limits
- Unfired; no superheater; gas-side-controlled U.
- The design economiser duty and LMTD are taken as given; they are not checked against the design gas and water temperatures, so enter a consistent design case.
- A steaming economiser is not modelled: the water is capped at saturation and the economiser duty kept sensible, so the stack temperature is overstated and the steam understated when the warning appears.
References
- Ganapathy
- Steam Plant Calculations Manual
- 2nd ed. (Marcel Dekker, 1993)
- Q4.35 (off-design simulation of an HRSG) and Q4.34 (design case)
- Q4.41 (steaming in the economiser); IAPWS-IF97 steam properties
Questions and answers
Why can't I scale steam with gas flow?
The evaporator's exit gas temperature rises and the economiser's pull changes with flow, temperature and pressure; the whole temperature profile shifts.
What does Ganapathy's example give?
Design 140,000 lb/h at 980 °F and 200 psig; at 165,000 lb/h, 880 °F and 150 psig: evaporator gas out 388 °F, 21.7 MM Btu/h, about 25,300 lb/h of steam, water out at saturation and stack about 300 °F.
Why does the economiser steam at off-design?
At lower drum pressure or higher gas flow, the economiser surface can heat water above the new saturation temperature.
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.