Worked example
Example: Duda Table 5.11.1 first row: 500 µm, Wi 12 kWh/sh t. The inputs, in the units selected above:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Feed 80 % passing size | 500.00 µm |
| Bond work index (metric tonne) | 13.228 kWh/t |
| Specific gravity of the feed | 2.7000 g/cm³ |
| Mill speed as a fraction of critical | 76.000 % |
| Mill diameter inside the liners | 9.0000 ft |
| Grinding | Wet grinding (K = 350) |
Applying the formula below gives:
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Make-up ball diameter | 15.842 mm |
| Equivalent make-up rod diameter | 19.486 mm |
Open this example in the calculator and change any input.
Formula
\(B = \sqrt{\frac{F}{K}}\sqrt[3]{\frac{W_i S}{C_s\sqrt{D}}}\ \ (\text{in; }F\ \mu m,\ W_i\ \text{kWh/sh t},\ C_s\ \%,\ D\ \text{ft})\)
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | SI unit |
|---|---|---|
| \(F\) | Feed 80 % passing size | m |
| \(W_i\) | Bond work index (metric tonne) | J/kg |
| \(S\) | Specific gravity of the feed | kg/m³ |
| \(C_s\) | Mill speed as a fraction of critical | - |
| \(D\) | Mill diameter inside the liners | m |
| \(K\) | Grinding | - |
| \(B\) | Make-up ball diameter | m |
| \(1.23B\) | Equivalent make-up rod diameter | m |
Method and standards
Bond's ball size formula.
Where it is used
- Selecting make-up ball size for cement and mineral mills.
- Charging a new mill.
Common mistakes
- Using the metric work index without conversion.
- Entering speed in rpm instead of percent critical.
Assumptions and limits
- Production-size mills.
References
- Duda
- Cement Data Book
- Vol. 1
- 3rd ed. (Bauverlag / Macdonald and Evans, 1985)
- sec. 5.11 (Bond's ball size formula) and Table 5.11.1
- Perry's Chemical Engineers' Handbook
- 9th ed.
- sec. 21 (rod to ball size ratio 1.23)
Questions and answers
Why does a coarser feed need larger balls?
Each ball must carry enough impact energy to break the largest particles; ball mass grows with the cube of its diameter.
Is it valid for laboratory mills?
No: Perry's notes the formula gives reasonable results for production mills but not for small laboratory mills.
What do the defaults represent?
The first row of Duda's Table 5.11.1: feed 500 µm, Wi 12 kWh per short ton, S 2.7, 76 % of critical, 9 ft mill (0.625 in).
Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 17 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.