FireCADCalc

Thermic Fluid Against Steam Heating: Annual Running Cost

Annual fuel and power cost of a process heat load by thermic fluid heater or by steam, including boiler, distribution and water treatment losses.

Refinery and petrochemicalChemical and fertiliserThermic fluid heatingPulp and paperFood, dairy and textile

Inputs

Examples: 1 MW, 7,000 h, fuel 500/GJ3 MW, coal 250/GJ, good steam system

Per GJ on the same calorific basis (GCV or NCV) as the two efficiencies.

Results

Running cost only; capital, safety (no pressure vessel above about 300 °C) and fluid replacement are separate. Thermic fluid wins most clearly when process temperatures exceed about 200 °C, where steam pressures become high.

Annual cost, thermic fluid1.5664e+07
Annual cost, steam1.8970e+07
Saving with thermic fluid3,306,651
Saving as share of steam cost17.431%

Download PDF CSV Link to this result Compare another case

Log in to save calculations to your dashboard.

Worked example

Example: 1 MW, 7,000 h, fuel 500/GJ. The inputs, in the units selected above:

InputValue
Process heat demand1,000.0 kW
Operating hours per year7,000.0 h
Fuel cost (currency per GJ)500.00 -
Electricity cost (currency per kWh)8.0000 -
Thermic fluid heater efficiency85.000 %
Thermic fluid pump power15.000 kW
Steam boiler efficiency82.000 %
Steam distribution, trap, flash and condensate losses15.000 %
Water treatment and blowdown cost per GJ of steam (currency)15.000 -
Feed pump and other steam-side power8.0000 kW

Applying the formula below gives:

ResultValue
Annual cost, thermic fluid1.5664e+07
Annual cost, steam1.8970e+07
Saving with thermic fluid3,306,651
Saving as share of steam cost17.431 %

Open this example in the calculator and change any input.

Formula

\(C_{tf} = \frac{Qt_a}{\eta_{tf}}c_f + P_{tf}t_ac_e, \quad C_{st} = \frac{Qt_a}{\eta_b(1 - f_s)}c_f + \frac{Qt_a}{1 - f_s}c_w + P_{fw}t_ac_e\)

Variables

Symbol Meaning SI unit
\(Q\) Process heat demand W
\(t_a\) Operating hours per year s
\(c_f\) Fuel cost (currency per GJ) -
\(c_e\) Electricity cost (currency per kWh) -
\(\eta_{tf}\) Thermic fluid heater efficiency -
\(P_{tf}\) Thermic fluid pump power W
\(\eta_b\) Steam boiler efficiency -
\(f_s\) Steam distribution, trap, flash and condensate losses -
\(c_w\) Water treatment and blowdown cost per GJ of steam (currency) -
\(P_{fw}\) Feed pump and other steam-side power W
\(C_{tf}\) Annual cost, thermic fluid -
\(C_{st}\) Annual cost, steam -
\(\Delta C\) Saving with thermic fluid -
\(\Delta C/C_{st}\) Saving as share of steam cost -

Method and standards

Annual cost definitions.

Where it is used

  • Choosing a heating medium for a new process.
  • Converting steam users to thermic fluid.

Common mistakes

  • Ignoring steam-side losses.
  • Comparing at different delivered temperatures.

Assumptions and limits

  • Same delivered heat.
  • The steam side has a distribution, trap, flash and condensate loss share; the thermic fluid loop has no separate distribution loss input, although its pipes also lose heat. Include that loss in the thermic fluid heater efficiency, or the comparison favours thermic fluid.
  • The fuel cost per GJ and both efficiencies must be on the same calorific basis (GCV or NCV).

References

  • Energy balance and annual cost definitions

Questions and answers

Where does thermic fluid save?

No flash, trap, condensate or blowdown losses and no water treatment; the fluid returns hot in a closed loop.

When is steam better?

For large loads at moderate temperature, direct injection, or where waste steam is already available.

What do the defaults give?

1 MW for 7,000 h at fuel 500 per GJ: thermic fluid about 156.6 lakh (1.57 crore) a year, steam about 189.7 lakh (1.90 crore), a saving of about 17 %.

Method and article reviewed by FireCAD engineering on 13 November 2026. Every result is checked against an independent calculation on each release: how we verify our calculators.

Related calculators

Free engineering calculators: every page computes in SI and converts to your units. Results are for engineering estimation; verify critical designs against the referenced standards.

Rejoining the server...

Rejoin failed... trying again in seconds.

Failed to rejoin.
Please retry or reload the page.

The session has been paused by the server.

Failed to resume the session.
Please retry or reload the page.